Skip to content

Pittsburgh Steelers vs Cincinnati Bengals Player-Prop Picks & Anytime Touchdown Bets for Thursday Night Football

Chris Amberley

By Chris Amberley in NFL News

Published:


DK Metcalf scores a touchdown versus the Browns in Week 6.
Oct 12, 2025; Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; Pittsburgh Steelers wide receiver DK Metcalf (4) makes a catch for a touchdown during the fourth quarter at Acrisure Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Barry Reeger-Imagn Images
  • The Steelers face the Bengals on Thursday Night Football
  • DK Metcalf leads Pittsburgh in red zone routes run and has scored in four straight games
  • See my favorite Steelers vs Bengals player prop picks and anytime touchdown bets for Thursday Night Football

AFC North rivals clash on Thursday Night Football, as the red-hot Steelers (4-1, 2-0 away) visit the Bengals (2-4, 1-1 home). Pittsburgh has reeled off three straight wins in large part thanks to the Aaron Rodgers to DK Metcalf connection. Those two will be featured in my Steelers vs Bengals player prop picks below, along with teammate Kenneth Gainwell.

Kickoff is slated for 8:15 pm ET from Paycor Stadium, in Cincinnati, OH, with Amazon Prime Video providing the broadcast coverage.

The first table below lists the main Steelers vs Bengals player props available in the TNF odds, plus my favorite O/Us to target. The second table features the first TD and anytime touchdown props.

PIT Steelers vs CIN Bengals Player Props

PasserCompletionsPassing YardsPassing TDs
Aaron Rodgers (PIT)20.5 (O -115 | U -111)219.5 (O -114 | U -114)1.5 (O -126 | U -102)
Joe Flacco (CIN)22.5 (O -128 | U +100)238.5 (O -114 | U -114)1.5 (O +144 | U -182)
RusherRushing AttemptsRushing YardsLongest Rush
Jaylen Warren (PIT)12.5 (O -108 | U -122)47.5 (O -114 | U -114)12.5 (O -126 | U -102)
Kenneth Gainwell (PIT)OFF23.5 (O -114 | U -114)OFF
Aaron Rodgers (PIT)OFF1.5 (O +112 | U -142)OFF
Chase Brown (CIN)12.5 (O -148 | U +112)46.5 (O -114 | U -114)10.5 (O -114 | U -114)
Samaje Perine (CIN)OFF16.5 (O -114 | U -114)OFF
ReceiverReceptionsReceiving YardsLongest Reception
DK Metcalf (PIT)4.5 (O -112 | U -112)66.5 (O -114 | U -114)25.5 (O -112 | U -118)
Jonnu Smith (PIT)3.5 (O -102 | U -126)27.5 (O -114 | U -114)13.5 (O -106 | U -125)
Darnell Washington (PIT)2.5 (O -126 | U -102)23.5 (O -114 | U -114)12.5 (O -126 | U -102)
Ja’Marr Chase (CIN)6.5 (O -130 | U +102)73.5 (O -114 | U -114)22.5 (O -114 | U -114)
Tee Higgins (CIN)4.5 (O +120 | U -154)46.5 (O -114 | U -114)19.5 (O -114 | U -114)
Noah Fant (CIN)3.5 (O -118 | U -108)28.5 (O -114 | U -114)13.5 (O -112 | U -118)
Andrei Iosivas (CIN)1.5 (O -118 | U -108)17.5 (O -114 | U -114)12.5 (O -114 | U -114)

Rodgers actually checks in with a lower passing odds prop than Cincy’s Joe Flacco, and he also project for fewer completions. Pittsburgh’s Jaylen Warren has the highest rushing yards over/under at 47.5, but I’m targeting Gainwell instead with my first player prop pick.

FANDUEL SPORTSBOOK
Bet $5 & Get $300 in Bonus Bets if Your Bet Wins

Must be 21+. T&C Apply. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

LOCK IN PROMO
SIGNUP PROMO
BET $5
GET $300

BET NOW
NFL player props as of Oct. 16 at FanDuel, DraftKings and bet365. Claim the FanDuel promo code before wagering on Thursday Night Football.

Steelers vs Bengals Player Prop Bet #1: Kenneth Gainwell Rushing Yards

The Steelers check in with a top-10 offense in EPA per play since Week 3. They’ve been extremely efficient through the air and on the ground, and there’s no better run defense to attack than Cincy’s.

The Bengals have allowed the most red zone production to enemy backs and the third most rushing yards per game. Pittsburgh will feature both Warren and Gainwell in this matchup, and I expect more carries than usual for the ladder as a large road favorite.

Bengals Defense Against the Run

StatTotal
Rush EPA0.039 (27th)
Opponent Rush Success Rate44.5% (24th)
Rushing Yards Allowed / Game119.7 (30th)

Pittsburgh already runs at the league’s 11th highest rate, and Gainwell enters play averaging nearly a yard more per carry than Warren. He also has three explosive runs, while Warren has none, making Gainwell a threat to clear this prop on any single attempt.

  • Kenneth Gainwell Over 23.5 yards (-114 at FanDuel); 1 unit

Steelers vs Bengals Player Prop Bet #2: Aaron Rodgers Passing Attempts

If you want to buy the Steelers as a serious Super Bowl 60 odds the arguments starts with Rodgers. He’s getting the ball out faster than ever, completing nearly 70% of his throws. He’s carving up defenses with efficiency and not volume, which makes the under on his passing attempts prop attractive.

Rodgers has cleared 30.5 passing attempts in only one start, and that was in a game versus Seattle where they trailed throughout. Given that Pittsburgh is most likely playing from ahead, plus the struggles of the Cincy run defense, it’s highly unlikely that he sees 31+ passing attempts tonight.

Steelers vs Bengals Touchdown Scorer Props

PlayerOdds to Score 1st TDAnytime TD Odds
Jaylen Warren (PIT)+450-135
Chase Brown (CIN)+650+105
Ja’Marr Chase (CIN)+750+145
DK Metcalf (PIT)+900+155
Kenneth Gainwell (PIT)+950+195
Tee Higgins (CIN)+1000+220
Jonnu Smith (PIT)+1600+330
Darnell Washington (PIT)+1700+370
Noah Fant (CIN)+1700+460
Roman Wilson (PIT)+2000+500
Steelers D/ST+2000+600
Samaje Perine (CIN)+2200+600
Scotty Miller (PIT)+2200+650
Pat Freiermuth (PIT)+3000+700
Bengals D/ST+3500+850

Moving over to the Steelers vs Bengals touchdown props, where Warren has the shortest odds to hit pay dirt at -135. A little further down the board we’ll find Metcalf, who’s established himself as Rodgers’ go-to target.

Bengals vs Steelers Prop Bet #3: DK Metcalf Anytime TD

Metcalf’s team-high 23% target share isn’t astronomical, but it jumped to 31% last week with Calvin Austin out. Austin is expected to sit again tonight, making Metcalf an appealing anytime touchdown bet.

He’s scored in four straight games coming in, and is just as likely to bust a long play as he is to catch a touchdown in close. Speaking of the red zone, he leads the team in routes run and targets inside the opposing team’s 20-yard line, with a 100% catch rate so far.

  • DK Metcalf Anytime TD (+155 at DraftKings); 1 unit

Sign Up for SBD’s Newsletter Now

Did you want the latest sports betting news, analysis, picks, betting trends, and relevant data straight to your inbox? If so, you’ll want to subscribe to SBD’s newsletter now!

Chris Amberley
Chris Amberley

Sports Writer

As SBD's resident Swiss Army Knife, Chris covers virtually every sport including NFL, PGA, NBA, MLB, NCAAB, NCAAF and the Olympics. A true grinder, he'd rather pick off small edges in the player props market than swing for the fences with a 5-leg parlay.

NFL NBA MLB NHL Golf NCAAF NCAAB Tennis

Recommended Reading