Seton Hall vs Butler Expert Picks & Prediction (Feb. 15)

• Seton Hall brings an aggressive defensive identity to Hinkle Fieldhouse, looking to compound Butler’s five-game losing streak
• Big East leading rebounder Michael Ajayi offers a high-value statistical floor on the prop market regardless of the game script
• Check out my Seton Hall vs Butler expert picks and predictions on Sunday, Feb. 15

Big East action highlights Sunday evening’s college basketball slate as the Seton Hall Pirates (17-8, 7-7 Big East, away, 15-10 ATS) travel to Indianapolis to face the reeling Butler Bulldogs (13-12, 4-10 Big East, home, 12-13 ATS) at Hinkle Fieldhouse. Tip-off is scheduled for 6:00 pm ET on February 15, with the broadcast carried nationally on Fox Sports 1.

One lengthy losing streak is guaranteed to end tonight: Seton Hall has dropped four straight road games, while Butler has lost five straight overall. Another loss on Sunday would drop the Bulldogs into a tie for dead-last in the conference. A victory for Seton Hall would put the Pirates alone in fourth and virtually guarantee them a top-five finish and bye to the quarterfinals of the Big East tournament (three teams are tied for sixth-place at 5-9).

Below, I have set out my top Seton Hall vs Butler picks, followed by the latest odds, and the betting splits.

Jump to: PICKS || ODDS || BETTING SPLITS

Seton Hall vs Butler Expert Picks, Predictions & Best Bets

The situation in Indianapolis is dire; beyond the losing streak, the Bulldogs are navigating a depleted backcourt with freshman standout Azavier Robinson out for the season and leading scorer Finley Bizjack listed as day-to-day with a wrist sprain. With the market reacting to these absences, handicapping this matchup requires a close look at how Seton Hall’s pressure defense matches up against a shorthanded host.

The betting market often reacts slowly to injury news, but the line movement here suggests sharps are already pricing in Butler’s lack of depth. We are looking to exploit the mismatch between a healthy, high-intensity defense and a turnover-prone offense missing its primary ball handlers.

ATS Pick: Seton Hall -2.0 (-110 at Fanatics)

The Pirates arrive at Hinkle with a defensive profile perfectly suited to exploit Butler’s current vulnerabilities. Seton Hall ranks among the conference elite in defensive efficiency, anchored by guard Adam Clark, who sits second in the Big East with 54 total steals (2.16 per game). Clark is coming off a monster 31-point performance against Providence, proving he can control the game on both ends.

Butler’s ball-security issues were already a concern – forward Michael Ajayi has committed 68 turnovers this season (2.72 per game) – but the absence of Robinson (wrist) and the potential limitation or absence of Bizjack removes two of the team’s facilitators. Without reliable ball-handling, Butler is likely to struggle against Seton Hall’s pressure, leading to live-ball turnovers and easy transition points. The Pirates are 6-2 straight up at Hinkle Fieldhouse since the 2019-20 season. Laying the short number is a high-value play.

Over/Under Prediction: Under 141.5 (-115 at Bet99)

The Seton Hall/Butler game total opened at 142.5 and has been bet down to 139.5 at many sportsbooks. If you live in Ontario, you can still get it at 141.5 at Bet99. While Hinkle Fieldhouse has seen high-scoring affairs this season, the situational metrics point toward a lower-scoring grind. Seton Hall’s defense allows just 65.4 points per game, and the Pirates rank just 275th nationally in tempo. Butler plays faster (137th in tempo) but isn’t exactly a run-and-gun offense.

Seton Hall also brings the 14th-rated defense in terms of efficiency, per KenPom. Head coach Shaheen Holloway will likely focus on suffocating a shorthanded/injured Butler attack. If Bizjack sits or is limited, Butler loses 17.4 PPG and its most reliable free-throw shooter (85.6%).

Seton Hall prefers to control the tempo through Clark, often dragging opponents into half-court sets. Unless Butler shoots an extreme outlier percentage from beyond the arc against a long, athletic perimeter defense, points will be at a premium. The college basketball public betting splits show 53% of tickets and 51% of handle on the over, yet the line has still dropped precipitously, a good indication of sharp action on the under.

The under is a perfect way to fade the public.

Top Player Prop to Bet: Michael Ajayi Over 10.5 Rebounds (+110 at FanDuel)

In a game where offensive efficiency is likely to plummet, rebounding volume is equally likely to rise. This prop offers the most significant statistical edge on the Sunday board. Michael Ajayi is the premier rebounder in the Big East, leading the conference in both total rebounds (283) and average (11.32 RPG), and sitting four nationally in the latter.

Seton Hall’s leading rebounder, Stephon Payne, averages just 7.24 boards per game. Ajayi’s usage rate is massive, logging 33.4 minutes per game (second in the Big East), and he will be forced to play heavy minutes given the roster depletion. Whether Butler keeps it close or trails early, Ajayi will be the primary option cleaning the glass on both ends.

Seton Hall vs Butler Odds & Probability

Sunday’s college basketball odds install Seton Hall as a short road favorite, a line that respects Butler’s home court but acknowledges their recent form and injury report. Converting the moneyline odds into implied win probabilities yields the following:

• Seton Hall: 59.68% implied win probability (based on the best-available moneyline of -148)
• Butler Win: 44.25% implied win probability (based on the best-available moneyline of +126)

For bettors playing the moneyline, a $20 wager on Seton Hall (-148) yields a total payout of $33.60 ($13.60 profit). Conversely, backing home underdog Butler (+126) with a $20 bet returns $45.20 ($25.20 profit). Given the trend data and roster availability, the risk-adjusted return heavily favors the visitors.

Both teams are massive longshots in the March Madness championship odds. Seton Hall is a +30000 longshot about 45th-best odds in the country) while Butler is a +100000 afterthought and highly unlikely to make the 68-team field.

Odds commentary as of 3:13 pm ET. The odds in the table will update automatically with the best-available price for each market. The sportsbooks each reader sees in the table may differ based on location.

Butler vs Seton Hall Public-Betting Splits

Tracking the money flow for this Big East clash reveals a distinct “pros-vs-joes” dynamic on the total, while the spread and moneyline show a market-wide abandonment of the home underdog in the college basketball public betting splits.

Spread & Moneyline: Liability on Road Favorite

The betting public and sharp bettors are aligned on the side, creating massive liability on Seton Hall.

• Spread: The Pirates are attracting 59.85% of the betting tickets, but a decisive 73.21% of the handle (money). When the handle percentage exceeds ticket count by this margin, it indicates larger, more sophisticated wagers backing the favorite.
• Moneyline: The sentiment is even more lopsided on the outright winner. While 74.2% of tickets are on Seton Hall, 95.29% of the cash is backing the visitors. The market clearly sees no value in backing a slumping, injured Butler squad.

Total: The Contrarian Angle

• The Consensus: The Over is the popular play, drawing 79.91% of bets and 75.95% of the money.
• The Edge: With nearly 80% of the public expecting points, playing the Under 143.5 aligns us with the defensive metrics and fades the public bias, a strategy that often pays dividends in conference play.

Seton Hall vs Butler: Statistical Comparison

The following table highlights the disparity between Seton Hall’s defensive stability and Butler’s high-variance style. Note the gap in points allowed and the rebounding mismatch.

Key Mismatch: Perimeter Defense vs Ball Security

The game will likely be decided by the turnover battle. Seton Hall’s Adam Clark (2.16 SPG) and AJ Staton-McCray (38 total steals) form a defensive backcourt that thrives on disruption. They face a Butler team that was already turning the ball over at a high clip—Ajayi has 68 TOs this season—and is now missing its primary ball-handler in Robinson. This statistical mismatch suggests Seton Hall will generate extra possessions and easy buckets.

Sign Up for SBD’s Newsletter Now

Did you want the latest sports betting news, analysis, picks, betting trends, and relevant data straight to your inbox? If so, you’ll want to subscribe to SBD’s newsletter now!