Upcoming Match-ups

Yankees & Red Sox 2019 Win Totals Both Set at 95.5; What’s the Best Bet for Each?

Aaron Judge
Aaron Judge admires yet another home run. Photo by Keith Allison (flickr) [CC License].
  • The Boston Red Sox and New York Yankees are both projected to win 95.5 games in 2019
  • Three other teams are expected to win at least 90 games
  • The Houston Astros lead all clubs with a projected win total of 96.5

There’s no better way to get through a cold winter than to survey 2019 MLB win totals the moment they’re available.  BetOnline has released totals for next year and five teams have a total set higher than 90 wins.

Win Totals for 2019 World Series Contenders

Team Win Total and Odds at BetOnline (01/23/19)
Houston Astros 96.5 (-115o/-115u)
Boston Red Sox 95.5 (-115o/-115u)
New York Yankees 95.5 (-115o/-115u)
Los Angeles Dodgers 94.5 (-115o/-115u)
Cleveland Indians 90.5 (-115o/-115u)

The thing that stands out most is BetOnline is that both the Boston Red Sox (95.5, -115o/-115u) and New York Yankees (95.5, -115o/-115u) share identical totals. Thankfully, you don’t need to pick the winner in the division, you just need to zero in on whether each team is headed north or south of that projection.

The Case for the Boston Red Sox

Boston won 108 games in the regular season, en route to winning the American League pennant and ultimately the World Series.  The status of closer Craig Kimbrel is still up in the air, but the Red Sox did make a major move signing Nathan Eovaldi to a four-year extension.

He was a key piece to last year’s World Series victory and will help round out the Red Sox rotation that includes Chris Sale, David Price, Rick Porcello, and Eduardo Rodriguez.  That is definitely a staff capable of not only winning more than 95 games, but of blowing it out of the water once again.

In the field and at the plate, Boston projects to look exactly like it did in 2018.  Many times World Series winners lose player after player in free agency, and while the bullpen did lose some of it’s depth, the offence did not.  Name a stat and Boston likely led the majors in it last year – AVG, OBP, runs, total bases, RBI – they were first in all of them.

Name a stat and Boston likely led the majors in it last year – AVG, OBP, runs, total bases, RBI – they were first in all of them.

Could there be a World Series hangover? Sure. But thankfully the folks at BetOnline have built in a 12.5 win cushion on last year’s win total for you, so it shouldn’t be much of a concern.  The Red Sox may not repeat as champs or even as division winners, but the over here looks great regardless.

Pick: Red Sox over 95.5 wins (-115)

The Case for the New York Yankees

The Yankees won 100 games in the regular season last year, a monster total overshadowed only by Boston’s historic run. Could they match that total, or for the sake of this bet, come within four games of it in 2019?  It certainly seems likely.

New York has a history of amazing bullpen arms, none more spectacular than Mariano Rivera, who just became the first player unanimously voted into Cooperstown.

That said, the Yankees bullpen in 2019 projects to possibly the best in team history.  Aroldis Chapman, Dellin Betances and Zach Britton return, while Adam Ottavino signed in free agency. Any game the Yankees get to the 6th inning is almost as much of a lock to be closed out as a 9th inning lead was in the Rivera Era. As for the rotation, New York is much more likely to get to those late innings with a lead after adding James Paxton and re-signing deadline acquisition JA Happ.

Any game the Yankees get to the 6th inning is almost as much of a lock to be closed out as a 9th inning lead was in the Rivera Era.

At the plate, expect the Yankees to mash just like they did in 2018.  Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton still headline a lineup more than capable of providing run production. The lineup, as is, has a good chance of going over the number, but now imagine they land Manny Machado, which is a definite possibility.

Much like Boston’s total, BetOnline was conservative in setting the number where it is, and you should take advantage.

PICK: Yankees over 95.5 wins (-115)

Author Image

Ryan has been working at TSN for over nine years, and is now a lead writer and content producer at That's Hockey. Over the years, he's launched and hosted TSN's first NCAAF podcast, The College Football Show, and been featured on the likes of TSN 1050, Sportscentre, and That's Hockey 2Nite.