The 2021 AL Playoff Odds Favor These Five Teams Making the AL Postseason

By Robert Duff in MLB Baseball
Published:

- The New York Yankees are given prohibitive -950 odds to make the American League playoffs
- Five other teams have opened as odds-on favorites to reach the postseason
- MLB is going back to its previous playoff format, meaning there are only five postseason spots up for grabs
MLB is returning to its prior playoff format and that’s going to be bad news for at least one AL team among the six showing minus odds in the opening betting market on which clubs will make the postseason in 2021.
The New York Yankees head the way. The Bronx Bombers are listed at a prohibitive betting line of -950 in the opening 2021 MLB playoff odds.
Beyond the Yanks, the Chicago White Sox (-288), Minnesota Twins (-151), Oakland Athletics (-123), Houston Astros (-111), and Toronto Blue Jays (-109) are also all better than even-money to earn one of the AL’s five postseason positions.
2021 AL Playoff Odds
Team | Odds To Make Playoffs | Odds to Miss Playoffs |
---|---|---|
New York Yankees | -950 | +600 |
Chicago White Sox | -288 | +225 |
Minnesota Twins | -151 | +125 |
Oakland Athletics | -123 | +100 |
Houston Astros | -111 | -111 |
Toronto Blue Jays | -109 | -114 |
Tampa Bay Rays | +115 | -139 |
Los Angeles Angels | +160 | -200 |
Cleveland | +240 | -313 |
Boston Red Sox | +278 | -368 |
Texas Rangers | +900 | -1600 |
Seattle Mariners | +1000 | -3500 |
Kansas City Royals | +1100 | -3750 |
Baltimore Orioles | +1200 | -2500 |
Detroit Tigers | +1200 | -2500 |
Odds as of Feb. 23rd.
The three division winners – AL East, Central, and West – and two Wild Card teams will qualify for the playoffs.
Lock Them Into MLB Playoffs
Yes, there’s uncertainty about the Yankees’ starting rotation. Doesn’t that seem to be evolving into an annual occurrence, though? The Bronx Bombers always manage to come up with enough serviceable arms to get the job done. And they can always outhit their pitching woes.
Sizzlin' pop 💥@GerritCole45 pic.twitter.com/bXVN0jEac2
— New York Yankees (@Yankees) February 22, 2021
Hiring 76-year-old Tony LaRussa as manager and adding closer Liam Hendriks, it’s clear the Chicago White Sox are going all-in to win this season. The Minnesota Twins can’t win once they get to the playoffs, yet they always find a way to get the to the playoffs.
There’s Value in These AL Plays
The Toronto Blue Jays were part of the expanded playoff picture last year. Bringing in free-agent outfielder George Springer and shortstop Marcus Semien, and considering Vladimir Guerrero’s sudden commitment to fitness, the Jays should grab a Wild Card spot this season.
George Springer and Marcus Semien are Toronto Blue Jays 😃 pic.twitter.com/7Lp904sqRl
— Toronto Blue Jays (@BlueJays) February 23, 2021
The departure of the likes of Francisco Lindor, Carlos Santana, Brad Hand and Carlos Carrasco from Cleveland has people thinking fire sale for this team that is to be renamed later. However, that’s not taking into account how deep the pitching staff is on this club.
Shane Bieber won the AL Cy Young Award and and then they follow with Zach Plesac and Aaron Civale. Cleveland won’t score a ton of runs, but if they score enough, those arms possess the talent to keep the team on the cusp of the playoff race.
Swing and a Miss
No matter how you roll with the Houston Astros, you’ll get -111 odds. The best play is to bet the Astros to be playoff outsiders. Minus Springer and pitcher Justin Verlander (elbow injury), this is no longer an elite ball club.
A rotation once fronted by Verlander and Gerrit Cole now runs out Zack Greinke, Lance McCullers Jr., and Framber Valdez as the top three starters. They’ll need some young pitchers and unproven outfielders to step up if Houston wants to maintain its four-year stretch of making the playoffs.
Blake Snell’s looking too fresh in brown and gold.@snellzilla4 • #PadresST pic.twitter.com/nfqiCuxfc4
— San Diego Padres (@Padres) February 21, 2021
Some teams play small ball. In Tampa Bay and Oakland, these teams play small-market ball.
The Athletics lost a ton of talent, including Semien and Hendriks. Tampa Bay waved goodbye to former AL Cy Young winner Blake Snell. Both of these clubs often decipher ways to patchwork over their economic disadvantages. But it’s hard to bet on the unknown.

Sports Writer
An industry veteran, Bob literally taught the course on the history of sports at Elder College. He has worked as a Sports Columnist for Postmedia, appeared as a guest on several radio stations, was the Vice President of the Society For International Hockey Research in Ontario, and written 25 books.