Upcoming Match-ups

Bengals vs Bills Props – Best Player Props to Bet for Divisional Round Playoffs

Chris Wassel

by Chris Wassel in NFL Football

Updated Jan 21, 2023 · 2:00 PM PST

Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen throws the football against the Cincinnati Bengals
Josh Allen and the Bills face off against the Bengals in a highly anticipated playoff showdown. Syndication The Enquirer
  • The Bengals play the Bills in the AFC Divisional Round on Sunday, January 22 in Orchard Park, New York
  • Buffalo Bills QB Josh Allen threw for 352 yards, three TD’s, and two INT’s last week against Miami
  • Read below for analysis and our favorite Bengals vs Bills props

It’s been almost three weeks since Josh Allen faced the Cincinnati Bengals. This will be like the game that finishes what both teams started. While Damar Hamlin continues his amazing recovery, Cincinnati and Buffalo faced off Sunday evening for the right to go to the AFC Championship. So let’s read on for some Bengals vs Bills props.

That game from early January helps us a grand total of zero. Cincinnati is now missing a few offensive linemen. Buffalo looked strangely vulnerable again last week versus a Miami team without Tua Tagovailoa.

As they meet on Sunday, it’s the Bills that are set as 5.5-point favorites in the contest. Let’s look at the best Bengals vs Bills player props and scoring props available below for your Cincinnati vs Buffalo picks.

Bengals vs Bills Player Props

Quarterback Completions Passing Yards Passing TDs
Joe Burrow (CIN) 26.5 (OV+102/Un-132) 277.5 (Ov-114/Un-114) 1.5 (Ov -132/Un+102)
Josh Allen (BUF) 22.5 (Ov-121/Un-107) 273.5 (Ov-114/Un-114) 1.5 (Ov-175/Un+130)
Running Back Attempts Rushing Yards Rushing TDs
Joe Mixon (CIN) 12.5 (Ov-129/Un+100) 47.5 (Ov-113/Un-115) OFF
Joe Burrow (CIN) OFF 11.5 (Ov-112/Un-117) OFF
Josh Allen (BUF) 8.5 (Ov+108/Un-139) 46.5 (Ov-114/Un-114) OFF
Devin Singletary (BUF) 9.5 (Ov-104/Un-125) 35.5 (Ov-114/Un-114) OFF
Wide Receivers & Tight Ends Receptions Receiving Yards Longest Reception
Stefon Diggs (BUF) 6.5 (Ov+105/Un-136) 80.5 (Ov-115/Un-113) OFF
Tee Higgins(CIN) 4.5 (Ov-167/Un+128) 63.5 (Ov-117/Un-112) OFF
Ja’Marr Chase (CIN) 7.5 (Ov+105/Un-136) 84.5 (Ov-115/Un-113) OFF
Gabriel Davis (BUF) 3.5 (Ov-137/Un+106) 56.5 (Ov-112/Un-115) OFF
Dawson Knox (BUF) 3.5 (Ov-103/Un-129) 36.5 (Ov-114/Un-114) OFF

All odds as of Jan. 21. Preview the newest Barstool Sportsbook promo code prior to kick-off today.

Allen and Burrow are both listed at 1.5 in their passing touchdown total in the table above. Ja’Marr Chase possesses the highest receiving yardage prop at 84.5 in the Bengals vs Bills picks.



Sign Up Today & Receive Up to
$1,050 in Bonuses!

Excludes MA.
& GET $1,050




This game kicks off at 3:00pm ET on Sunday, January 22 at the Highmark Stadium in Orchard Park, New York. The weather forecast is calling for snow showers and temperatures in the 30’s.

CBS is carrying the broadcast in the USA, with streaming available through fuboTV. DAZN is carrying the game in Canada.

Bengals vs Bills Props #1: Josh Allen Over 22.5 Completions

With Cincinnati’s secondary ranking in the bottom third in yards allowed and attempts, Josh Allen looks to throw the ball a little more much like last week against Miami. Do not be scared off by the weather forecast. Snow showers is a far cry from heavy snow bursts. The line of scrimmage remains a concern and Allen can get us just across the finish line once again.

Taking Allen to go Over 1.5 passing touchdowns could connect again on Sunday. Allen could come in right around that 23-26 completion range too. As an aside, with a game as contentious as this, Joe Burrow figures to go over 26.5 competitions at +102 also.

Pick: Josh Allen over 22.5 completions (-121), 1 unit.

Bengals vs Bills Props #2: Joe Burrow And Josh Allen Interception Double

When it comes to this NFL season, it makes sense to go with one of the safest props out there. These two quarterbacks take a number of risks. Therefore, Joe Burrow and Josh Allen inevitably make mistakes. Buffalo and Cincinnati know this coming in and if one is looking for an odd parlay, this is it.

Again, for our purposes, playing the safer money on a few game-changing mistakes feels like a safe wager on Sunday afternoon among a few snowflakes.

Picks: Josh Allen over 0.5 interceptions (-148), 1 unit. Joe Burrow over 0.5 interceptions (-141), 1 unit.

Bengals vs Bills Scoring Props

Player Odds to Score First TD Odds to Score Any TD
Stefon Diggs (BUF) +700 +100
Josh Allen (BUF) +800 +123
Joe Mixon (CIN) +800 +130
Ja’Marr Chase (CIN) +800 +107
Gabriel Davis (BUF) +950 +155
James Cook (BUF) +1000 +170
Devin Singletary (BUF) +1050 +170
Tee Higgins (CIN) +1100 +160
Dawson Knox (BUF) +1150 +190
Isaiah McKenzie (BUF) +1600 +290
Tyler Boyd (CIN) +1700 +295

Stefon Diggs and Ja’Marr Chase are both odds-on favorites to find the endzone in the NFL Divisional Weekend props.

Bengals vs Bills Props #3: Joe Mixon Under 47.5 Yards

This looks to be a reasonable risk on Sunday as Joe Mixon cannot seem to get going lately. He has games of 27 and 39 yards rushing the past two weeks. Buffalo’s rushing defense ranks fifth in yards allowed at just under 100 a contest. That limits Mixon’s chances and helps ours on Sunday.

Honestly, the math works in our favor here. Mixon averaged 12.5 carries the past four weeks. So, if he hits that 3.5 average, that computes to around 43 yards.

Pick: Joe Mixon under 47.5 yards rushing (-115), 1 unit. 

Bengals vs Bills Props #4: Dawson Knox Anytime Touchdown

This prop is worth a tiny wager on Sunday but worth a shot. The Josh Allen to Dawson Knox combination connected in five straight games in the end zone. Now, that becomes worth a flier.

Pick: Dawson Knox anytime TD (+190), 1 unit.


Must be 21+ and in OH. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

Author Image