Upcoming Match-ups

Odds on Who Barstool’s Dave Portnoy Will Marry Next

JJ De La Torre

by JJ De La Torre in Entertainment

Mar 30, 2021 · 12:13 PM PDT

Dave Portnoy's Next Wife - Ramona Singer, Addison Rae & Madison Beer
Ramona Singer attends WE TV's "Bridezillas" Season 11 premiere party at Arena on Thursday, Feb. 22, 2018, in New York. (Photo by Charles Sykes/Invision/AP)
  • In 2017, Dave Portnoy and Renee Satherthwaite announced they were divorcing after 12 years together and eight of marriage
  • The Barstool Sports founder has had his share of ups and downs in love and lust following the split including a sex tape scandal
  • Who will Portnoy’s next wife be? See odds and best bets below

Founder and ‘El Presidente’ of Barstool Sports blog Dave Portnoy is certainly a hit with the ladies. The 44-year-old Swampscott, Massachusetts native is definitely no stranger to publicity, either.

Having had a few high-profile romances in addition to his career-related fame and notoriety, Portnoy’s relationship status is often observed with a magnifying glass.

Whether it’s a decade-plus long relationship or a wild sex tape rendezvous, Portnoy has seen and done it all it seems. Though he’s apparently single at the moment, the beloved ladies man is one of the more eligible famous men at the moment.

So, who will tame this wild beast for once and for all and get Portnoy to put a ring on it?

Odds for Who Barstool’s Dave Portnoy Will Marry Next

Potential Wife Odds
Ramona Singer +700
Alexis Ren +900
Anastasia Karanikolauo +900
Anitta +900
Kaitlynn Carter +1000
Madison Lacroix +1000
Paige Lorenze +1000
Savannah Montano +1100
Sofia Richie +1100
Kat Timpf +1500
McKayla Maroney +1500
Victoria Fuller +1500
Lana Rhoades +2500
Madison Beer +2500
Tana Mongeau +2500
Josie Canseco +6000
Kate Beckinsale +8000
Addison Rae +9000
Ashley Benson +10000
Trysta Krick +10000

Odds as of March 30th

Dave Portnoy’s History

Dave Portnoy’s current relationship status is a little unclear. In February, PageSix reported Portnoy had entered a relationship with 24-year-old former NFL cheerleader Shannon St. Clair, 20 years his junior.

But those reports seemed to have fizzled. There’s no recent evidence that Portnoy and St. Clair are actually together now. Perhaps they were just friends or the fling was brief. Maybe they’re actually together and keeping it uncharacteristically quiet.

Either way, oddsmakers seem to have counted Portnoy and St. Clair’s fling as a moot point– St. Clair isn’t even listed in the odds at all as a potential future wife for Portnoy. Clearly, oddsmakers don’t see a future here.

Looking Back

Portnoy is known to have spent last winter in Miami and was seen and photographed out and about with multiple women. He was spotted with St. Clair at multiple nightclubs before the relationship rumors hit the web in February. It looks like Portnoy isn’t settling down again anytime soon.

A quick primer in Portnoy’s love history: After his marriage to Renee Sathertwaite from 2009 to 2017, he went on to date fitness guru Jordyn Hamilton the same year. But since then, Portnoy’s relationship status has been a little hazy.

In December 2019, a sex tape leaked online showing Portnoy with an unidentified blonde woman. The entire escapade may have been headline fodder but what it did prove is that Portnoy isn’t presently in husband mode.

Examining the Odds

While Portnoy plays the field, the online community is clamoring to figure out who he will finally settle down with.

Potential options in odds include Ramona Singer at +700. Singer is a 64-year-old recently divorced star of Real Housewives of New York. Last fall, the two were spotted together. Portnow vehemently denied the claims, though.

24-year-old social media star Alexis Ren also has great odds in this race, at +900. Ren is a frequently seen name on Portnoy’s Barstool Sports, so she’s certainly in his line of vision. But there’s no evidence the two are leading toward a relationship.

Long shots in this race include singer Madison Beer (+2500), who revealed on a recent Barstool episode that she can’t leave her home because of paparazzi. Perhaps Beer and Portnoy could combine their fortunes and shack themselves in a shared compound.

Speaking of long shots, one of the worst odds in this prop may be worth looking at a little closely: Addison Rae. Recently, Portnoy called out Rae’s ex-Bryce Hall for keeping their relationship on the down-low while it was happening.

With odds of +9000, Rae isn’t the most likely. But perhaps Portnoy’s recent exchange with her ex will be the start of something between the two. Hey, it’s Hollywood. Stranger things have happened.

Pick: Addison Rae (+9000)

Author Image