Pirates vs Yankees Predictions, Best Bets & Splits on July 22

• Gerrit Cole faces his former team
• The Yankees won Game 1 on Monday
• Keep reading for my Pirates vs Yankees predictions

---

The New York Yankees (56-44) and Pittsburgh Pirates (52-49) are continuing their series in the Bronx. In their previous matchup on July 20, the Yankees secured an 8-5 victory, fueled by two home runs from Jazz Chisholm Jr.

First pitch for this interleague clash is scheduled for 1:05 PM ET on July 22, 2026, at Yankee Stadium. You can catch the broadcast on YES and SportsNet PT. I will break down the pitching duel, analyze offensive trends, and highlight the best wagers to help you find an edge today.

Yankees vs Pirates Picks & Predictions

When evaluating how to attack this matchup, I immediately look at the glaring discrepancy on the mound. New York boasts a massive pitching advantage, carrying a sharp 3.42 team ERA into this afternoon’s contest.

Conversely, the Pirates pitching staff has struggled to limit damage, logging a 4.30 overall ERA. While traditional game totals fluctuate, the statistical profiles strongly favor a New York victory today. Because the rotation profiles so much better, bypassing the traditional moneyline to isolate the MLB player props market is where I see significant value.

The data points directly to several extreme situational trends. Nick Gonzales has exceeded 1.5 total bases in 89% of his last nine road games (8 of 9). Henry Davis has exceeded 0.5 hits in 83% of his last six road games.

Ryan O’Hearn has stayed under 0.5 RBIs in eight of his last nine games on the road, failing to clear the number 89% of the time. With these situational trends in mind, here are my concrete betting angles:

Winner Prediction: Yankees Moneyline (-170, BetMGM)

Gerrit Cole is pitching for a staff that severely outclasses Pittsburgh’s. With Mitch Keller bringing an elevated 5.14 individual ERA to the Bronx, New York is perfectly positioned to capitalize.

Over/Under Pick: Mitch Keller OVER 2.5 Earned Runs (-150)

Rather than targeting a full-game total, I prefer fading the visiting starter. Keller has surrendered plenty of damage across his 103.1 innings. Asking him to hold a capable lineup under three earned runs is a tall order.

Best Player Prop: Nick Gonzales OVER 1.5 Total Bases (+141)

At significant plus-money at BetMGM, Gonzales is the sharpest prop on the board. He clears this exact line at an 89% clip on the road, making this a high-value wager.

Gerrit Cole vs Mitch Keller Pitching Matchup

The most significant edge in this game resides on the mound. The Yankees are sending elite ace Gerrit Cole to the bump, while the Pirates will counter with Mitch Keller.

Cole provides exceptional stability every time he pitches. Through 10 starts (55.0 innings) this season, he has produced a 3.93 ERA backed up by an identical 3.94 FIP. This suggests he is pitching exactly to his baseline.

He has maintained an impressive 1.16 WHIP while flashing consistent swing-and-miss stuff. He strikes out 9.00 batters per nine innings and holds opponents to a .242 batting average.

Conversely, Pittsburgh relies on Keller to navigate a tough road environment despite rocky performances. Through 19 starts, Keller holds a 5.14 ERA. He struggles to finish at-bats, generating just 6.71 strikeouts per nine innings.

Over his last 10 appearances, Keller’s numbers have plummeted. During this stretch, he has allowed opponents to bat .291 while posting a 6.75 ERA and a 1.58 WHIP. He is also issuing 3.55 walks per nine innings.

Pirates Batters vs Gerrit Cole

Yankees Batters vs Mitch Keller

Looking at historical MLB batter vs pitcher stats, several Yankees boast tremendous success against Keller. Cody Bellinger holds a .385 AVG with four extra-base hits in 13 career at-bats. Trent Grisham has hit .500 across 12 at-bats.

On the other side, Cole dominates the most experienced batters in the visiting lineup. Brandon Lowe strikes out at a high clip (17 times in 40 at-bats) with a .175 average. Ryan O’Hearn manages just a .105 average, making him a strong fade candidate in the prop market.

Team Statistics & Betting Trends

Comparing home situational statistics against road numbers reveals striking mismatches. Here is how both teams perform in key metrics.

* Denotes home rank. ** Denotes away rank.

New York claims the absolute best pitching staff in baseball with a 3.42 team ERA. This paints a stark contrast to a vulnerable Pittsburgh staff ranked 20th. With Cole toeing the rubber today, the home side holds an immediate structural advantage.

Offensively, Pittsburgh produces slightly more raw hits and runs in away games than New York does at home. They average 4.96 runs on the road with a .250 batting average. New York hits .238 in the Bronx and averages 4.87 runs.

However, New York outclasses their opponent in contact quality and extra-base power. They hold a significantly higher home OPS (.766) and an 89.0 mph average exit velocity. Furthermore, they lead all 30 clubs with 1.21 stolen bases per game at home.

• New York is 3-0 (100%) when playing as the betting favorite over their last 10 games.
• The Under has hit in 60.0% of New York’s last 10 matchups.
• The Under has cashed in just 35.6% of Pittsburgh’s games overall this season.
• The Over has hit in 70.0% of Pittsburgh’s last 10 contests.
• Pittsburgh has won 75.0% of their games (3-1) as a favorite over their last 10 outings.

Yankees vs Pirates Odds & Public Betting

Odds as of July 22, 2026, at 10:11 AM ET from BetMGM.

New York enters as a heavy home favorite on the moneyline at -178. This line heavily reflects the structural mismatch on the mound. Pittsburgh offers plus-money upside at +148 for those anticipating an upset, but the statistical profile points toward the Bronx.

When lines opened, the runline spread was New York -1.5 (+118) and Pittsburgh +1.5 (-142). The payout for the favorite to cover has since shortened to +113, indicating early money backing a multi-run victory.

While the opening game total began at a flat 9.5 (-110 on both sides), the juice aggressively shifted. The Under moved from -110 to -118. I attribute this line movement to bettors trusting Cole to suppress opposing bats.

Analyzing the MLB public betting splits reveals unified market sentiment on the sides. New York commands 88.8% of the moneyline betting tickets and a staggering 99.0% of the total cash wagered. The runline sentiment remains consistent, with 84.5% of the money backing the -1.5 spread.

The total runs market reveals a notable split. The Under accounts for 62.0% of all betting tickets, but 58.5% of the actual money lands on the Over. This indicates larger wagers bank on offensive fireworks, though it does not meet the 60% threshold for a definitive sharp vs public play.

Injury Reports & Betting Impact

Navigating the MLB odds requires a firm understanding of team health. Both dugouts are dealing with significant absences ahead of this afternoon’s clash.

New York navigates life without a massive chunk of their offensive identity. With superstar Aaron Judge sidelined, they miss their most feared bat. This lack of top-end power explains why they rely heavily on speed and manufacturing runs at home.

Furthermore, with multiple starting pitchers dealing with elbow injuries, Cole’s role is magnified. The team desperately needs him to chew up innings today – especially given the doubleheader.

On the other side, the absence of dynamic outfielder Oneil Cruz strips Pittsburgh of raw power and elite speed. Without his ability to change a game, the offense leans on contact-oriented players to string hits together on the road.

Additionally, with Endy Rodríguez and Spencer Horwitz dealing with ailments, their offensive depth is compromised. This makes the prospect of facing a dominant arm like Cole even more daunting.