Upcoming Match-ups

Yankees Still Have 3rd Best World Series Odds Despite Severino Setback

Chris Amberley

by Chris Amberley in MLB Baseball

Updated Mar 23, 2020 · 1:27 PM PDT

Luis Severino
The Yankees remain a serious title contender, despite the absence of starter Luis Severino. Photo by Arturo Pardavilla III (Flickr)
  • The New York Yankees remain in the World Series conversation despite dealing with significant injuries
  • The Yankees have lost a Major League high 471 games to injury already this season
  • How good can this team be if fully healthy?

The New York Yankees are dropping like flies. They’ve lost an MLB high 471 games to injury already this season and will now be without ace Luis Severino until at least mid-July.

You’d think a rash of injuries this severe would cripple any Major League franchise, but the Yankees continue to win ball games and their average World Series odds have barely moved.

2019 World Series Odds

Team Odds
Houston Astros +450
Los Angeles Dodgers +500
New York Yankees +500
Chicago Cubs +1000
Philadelphia Phillies +1100
St. Louis Cardinals +1100
Tampa Bay Rays +1100
Boston Red Sox +1500
Milwaukee Brewers +1500
Minnesota Twins +1600

*Odds taken on 05/07/19

They remain a top championship contender thanks to major production from some unheralded names, most notably Luke Voit.

Voit Is an Emerging Star

With sluggers Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton stuck on the DL, Voit has emerged as New York’s savior. He has a team high 29 RBI and is among the Yankee leaders in home runs, OBP, slugging, and WAR.

He’s hit more home runs than any other first baseman in baseball and is having a better statistical season than perennial All-Star Paul Goldschmidt, despite earning roughly 25 times less than him.


He began the season by reaching base in 31 consecutive games and he’s a major reason why the Yankees have a +40 run differential, despite so many injuries.

New York’s Pitching is Unsustainable

As good as Voit has been, the collection of pitchers filling in for Severino (and now James Paxton) have been nearly as impressive. New York has allowed the fourth fewest runs in the American League and are producing almost three times as many strikeouts as walks.


However, a closer look at the numbers suggest this level of performance is unsustainable. Yankees pitchers currently have a strand rate well above average and a BABIP well below average. They are getting uncharacteristic production from pitchers like Domingo German, whose home run to fly ball rate is more than three times lower than his career average, and whose BABIP is 96 points lower than a season ago.

Yankees pitchers currently have a strand rate well above average and a BABIP well below average.

Negative regression is likely coming, but it might not matter if New York can get healthy soon, and stop relying on second tier options.

The Yankees’ Odds Don’t Offer Value

Fortunately for the Yankees, most of the injuries to their star players are considered minor, with the exception of Severino. The fact that they’ve been able to stay competitive throughout is actually bad for their World Series odds, because it’s prevented them from dipping to the point where they can be considered a value.

+500 is too short to buy at the moment because even when they return to full health they should still be a much bigger underdog to more complete teams like the Astros and Dodgers.

Author Image