Houston Astros vs Toronto Blue Jays Odds, Picks & Player Props

• The Toronto Blue Jays send Shane Bieber to the mound to face Luis Garcia and the visiting Houston Astros
• Toronto has a stellar 15-4 record in its last 19 home games against teams with a winning record
• See the Astros vs Blue Jays odds, picks, and player props to target on Tuesday, Sep. 9

A massive game in the AL playoff race takes place on Tuesday as the Houston Astros (78-66, 35-34 away, 65-71-8 O/U) visit the Toronto Blue Jays (82-61,45-24 home, 80-57-6 O/U) at 7:07 pm ET at the Rogers Centre. Both teams hold slim two-game leads at the top of their divisions, while the Jays lead the Tigers by just half a game for first in the AL.

Questions surround the Houston starter Luis Garcia (1-0, 4.50 ERA). Coming back from Tommy John surgery, Garcia made his first appearance since 2023 last week, going six innings but allowing two homers to Angels. Toronto’s Shane Bieber (2-1, 4.15 ERA) was moved up in the rotation to replace the struggling José Berríos.

With the high-upside Bieber on the mound, Toronto is a sizable favorite in Tuesday’s MLB odds.

Go to: Odds | Pitcher-vs-Batter Stats | Player Props | Picks

Blue Jays vs Astros Odds

At the time of publication (11:55 am ET), the best moneyline price on the Blue Jays was -155 at bet365, while the longest odds on a Houston win were +135 at BetMGM. FanDuel had the best Astro runline (+1.5 at -156) and Caesars had the best Blue Jay runline (-1.5 at +140).

The total was 8.5 runs across the board with juice on the under. DraftKings was offering the best over odds (-102). ESPN Bet and bet365 had the best under odds (-115).

THESCORE BET

Offer

T&Cs

Get a 100% Bet Reset Up To $1,000 if Your First Bet Loses
Must manually enter promo code DIME to claim offer.

Must be 21+, offer available in AZ, CO, IA, IL, IN, KS, KY, LA, MA, MD, NC, NY, OH, TN & VA. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

LOCK IN PROMO

CODE: DIME

CODE: DIME

SIGNUP OFFER

USE PROMO CODE
DIME

$1,000 BET RESET!

GET OFFER NOW

HOU vs TOR Odds Movement

The betting market has seen some noteworthy shifts since the opening lines were posted. Houston opened as a -120 favorite when the pitching matchup was Garcia against a struggling Berrios. After Bieber replaced Berrios, the line swung heavily to the Jays. Toronto is currently getting 60% of moneyline handle on 67% of ML bets in Tuesday’s MLB public betting splits.

There was also significant movement on the total. It opened at a standard 8.5 runs with -110 juice both ways. However, the current line shows the under juiced to at least -118.

This movement aligns with a recent head-to-head trend: the last four games between these teams have stayed under the total.

Starting Pitcher vs Batter History: Garcia vs Bieber

Garcia has ample history (80 at-bats) against the Toronto hitters, and it’s been mostly favorable to the Houston starter. Bieber has roughly half as much experience against the Houston lineup (46 at-bats) and the results haven’t been nearly as good for the Toronto starter.

Houston Astros Career Statistics vs Shane Bieber

Houston’s lineup has mashed Bieber to the tune of a .304 average and .882 OPS. Carlos Correa and Christian Walker both have home runs off the Blue Jay righty, while Jose Altuve is 3-for-6 with a double and a walk.

Toronto Blue Jays Career Statistics vs Luis Garcia

The Jays have largely struggled against 28-year-old righty Garcia, with a .250 average and subpar .622 OPS. They have just two home runs in 80 at-bats, both courtesy of George Springer.

Concerningly for Toronto, the heart of their lineup – Bo Bichette and Vlad Guerrero Jr – are a combined 3-for-23 against Garcia with no extra-base hits.

Astros vs Blue Jays Player Props

MLB player props represent consensus lines across sportsbooks on Sep. 9.

George Springer stands out as a player to watch in the prop market. He has absolutely dominated Luis Garcia in his career, slugging 1.984 with two home runs in just seven at-bats. His total-bases prop at O 1.5 (+108) offers value given this history. As mentioned, Guerrero and Bichette have struggled mightily against Garcia, combining to go 3-for-21. This makes their under props on hits or total bases intriguing.

For Houston, Garcia’s strikeout prop is set at a low 3.5, but the over is heavily juiced at -159. The Blue Jays lineup does have swing-and-miss potential, but Garcia’s limited workload this season makes the over on his outs-recorded prop (15.5) a risky bet.

Houston Astros vs Toronto Blue Jays Picks & Prediction

• Toronto Blue Jays Moneyline (-155) at bet365
• Under 8.5 Runs (-115) at ESPN Bet
• Springer over 1.5 total bases (+108)

While the Astros swept the Blue Jays in a three-game series back in April, this matchup shifts to the Rogers Centre, where Toronto has been exceptionally tough to beat. The Blue Jays enter on a two-game skid after dropping their Saturday and Sunday matchups with the Yankees in New York, and they are an impressive 8-1 SU in their last nine home games following a defeat. The Blue Jays are also an astounding 15-4 in their last 19 home games against teams with a winning record.

Those trends are too powerful to ignore against an Astros team that has struggled on the road, going just 1-5 in their last six road games against winning opponents.

While Luis Garcia has had success against some of Toronto’s top hitters, George Springer has been his kryptonite. If Springer can set the tone at the top of the order, it could unravel Garcia, who struggled with flyballs in his first start since his TJ surgery. The Astros’ offense has been inconsistent, and their bullpen is significantly weakened without closer Josh Hader. Toronto’s offense, which boasts a superior team OPS (.771 to .719), should be able to do enough damage to support Bieber.

The most compelling betting angle outside of the moneyline is the total. The under has cashed in the last four meetings between these clubs.