Skip to content

CFTC Nominees: Regulatory Fight Over Sports Event Contracts Best Left to Courts

Robert Linnehan

By Robert Linnehan in Industry

Published:


Two CFTC nominees, Nathan Anonick (left) and Matthew Rowland, today discussed regulatory control over sports event contracts at a nomination hearing.
  • The Senate Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry Committee today held a hearing for two Commodity Futures Trading Commission nominees
  • President Donald J. Trump nominated Republican candidate Nathan Anonick and Democrat candidate Matthew Rowland to the commission
  • Both nominees held firm to their opinion the courts should determine regulatory control over sports event contracts

Two bipartisan nominees for the Commodity Futures Trading Commission today held firm to their opinion that the courts should have the final say of regulatory control over sports event contracts, but promised to meet with any stakeholders willing to discuss the issue.

The U.S. Senate Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry Committee today held a hearing for Republican nominee Nathan Anonick, a senior counsel member for Sen. John Boozman (R-AR), and Democrat nominee Matthew Rowland, a longtime Commodity Futures Trading Commission. President Donald J. Trump (R) nominated the bipartisan candidates to fill two of the four open seats on the CFTC.

Both are hoping to be approved to serve on the CFTC and to join Chairman Michael Selig, who has served as the lone commission for the last year.

Neither Nominees Touch Sports Betting Question

If both are approved to serve on the CFTC, it will bring the commission’s total number up to three, leaving two seats still unfilled.

As expected, the topic of regulatory power of sports event contracts was brought up by a number of Senators during the hearing. Sen. Amy Klobuchar (D-MN) asked both nominees to discuss the potential role of the CFTC for sports event contract regulations compared with the states role.

Both Anonick and Rowland said the question has been discussed in federal and district courts for the last year, with a consensus yet to be reached. The U.S. Supreme Court will likely have the final say over regulatory power of these new markets and the CFTC would be bound by the court’s decision.

Sen. Tina Smith (D-MN) pressed harder, asking both point blank if they believed sports event contracts were any different than sports bets.

“I know there have been courts that have held both ways on this issue … I think that going to the heart of the legal issue, it’s hard for me to comment on the active litigation the CFTC is engaged in. I’m certainly very sympathetic to the concerns the states and tribes have raised and will want to work with them further on this,” Rowland said.

Anonick said its a complex legal question that federal courts have disagreed on and he would not want to “tip the scales” from a legal perspective by weighing in the question.

“I’ve heard from tribes as well. It’s a charged, emotional issue, and I appreciate how sensitive it is,” Anonick said.

Heated Moment Regarding Selig

Perhaps the most heated moment of the hearing came from Sen. Adam Schiff (D-CA) who said current CFTC Chairman Selig may have “blatantly deceived” him more than any other nominee.

During his November 2025 nominee hearing, Schiff reminded his fellow committee members that Selig pledged to “follow the courts” regarding sports event contract regulations and described himself as a “blank slate” when it came to his opinion on regulatory control over the markets.

“He said he was a blank slate. I don’t know whether he was lying to us, or once confirmed he had an epiphany, but he has been anything but a blank slate. He has not looked to the courts, he has filed briefs telling the courts what to do. When the courts have ruled in a way that doesn’t the favor the prediction markets, he has basically told companies to ignore the courts, ignore court orders, don’t geofence, don’t respect state or tribal laws. Anything but a blank slate. I don’t know if I’ve ever been so blatantly deceived by a nominee before,” Schiff said.

Schiff asked both Anonick and Rowland the same question he asked Selig during his hearing. Is a sports event contract on Thursday night’s NFL matchup between the Colts and Texans the same as sports betting?

Anonick said he “could only speak for himself” and the question is complex, noting that federal courts have disagreed on the answer.

“I appreciate the practical argument. I just say it’s legally complex,” he said.

Both Anonick and Rowland said if confirmed they will fully support any U.S. Supreme Court decision on the issue.

Robert Linnehan
Robert Linnehan

Regulatory Writer and Editor

Robert Linnehan covers all regulatory developments in online gambling and sports betting. He specializes in U.S. sports betting news along with casino regulation news as one of the most trusted sources in the country.

Gambling

Recommended Reading