Heisman Odds After Week 12: Who Gained Ground Before Rivalry Week?
By Brady Trettenero in College Football
Published:
- Jeremiah Smith still leads the Heisman odds after Week 12
- A Utah quarterback has climbed into second place on the board
- See the full week-over-week Heisman odds comparison below
Jeremiah Smith turned six catches into 165 yards and two touchdowns at Nebraska. Ohio State dropped a 31-28 decision at Nebraska, but BetMGM moved the Buckeyes receiver further ahead of the field.
Behind him, the board reshuffled. Utah quarterback Devon Dampier is second now, and he got there partly by holding his ground while Miami’s Darian Mensah slid. Dampier’s own number is actually longer than it was a week ago, which tells you how far Mensah fell.
Wake Forest’s Gio Lopez also moved up after accounting for four touchdowns at Georgia Tech. Here’s where the Heisman Trophy odds stand against last Sunday’s board, plus where the value sits with Ohio State and Michigan still to come.
Updated Heisman Odds After Week 12
Odds from BetMGM as of Nov. 22, with last week’s prices taken from our Nov. 15 installment. See the BetMGM promo code page, and compare numbers across the best college football betting apps.
Smith’s -556 price implies roughly an 84.7% chance before the book’s margin, up from 64.5% at -182 last Sunday. That’s a steep price with Michigan still on the schedule. A $100 bet at -556 would earn about $18 in profit if Smith wins.
Smith’s Heisman Odds Shorten Through a Loss
Smith caught six passes for 165 yards and two touchdowns at Nebraska, with a long of 67 yards. That comes out to 27.5 yards a catch on a day Ohio State lost by three.
Didn't take long for your weekly Jeremiah Smith TD 💥
— Big Ten Network (@BigTenNetwork) November 21, 2026
Watch on FOX pic.twitter.com/jcxaBHRZLW
His longest catch accounted for 67 of those yards. Ohio State’s loss left a mark on the Buckeyes’ record, but the comparison with last Sunday shows how much more expensive Smith has become to back.
Devon Dampier Climbs to Second in the Heisman Odds
Dampier went 18-of-28 for 278 yards and two touchdown passes without an interception in Utah’s 38-17 win at TCU. He added 62 rushing yards and two more scores on 21 carries, so four total touchdowns on the night.
NEVER A DOUBT‼️ UTES WIN‼️ Utah: 38 TCU: 17
— Utah Football (@Utah_Football) November 22, 2026
His price moved twice. He sat at +1100 while the game was still in progress and came down to +700 once it went final.
Even after that late move, Dampier pays more than he did last Sunday at +500. He passed Mensah in the betting order because Miami’s quarterback drifted even further.
Mensah and Carr Keep Sliding Down the Heisman Board
Mensah threw two interceptions in Miami’s 28-20 win over Virginia Tech and finished with 241 passing yards. His quote went from +350 out to +1500, which cuts his implied chance from 22.2% down to 6.25%.
Carr drifted from +1000 to +3000, Gunner Stockton went +2000 to +5000, and Keelon Russell more than doubled out to +10000. Oklahoma State quarterback Drew Mestemaker also drifted from +3000 to +12500.
Gio Lopez Shortens to Fourth in the Heisman Odds
Lopez was 17-of-22 for 324 yards and two touchdowns in Wake Forest’s 50-29 win over Georgia Tech. He ran for 18 yards and two more scores on top of that.
Lopez shortened from +8000 to +2500. He now sits ahead of Notre Dame’s CJ Carr, who was a much shorter price than Lopez last Sunday. Tennessee running back DeSean Bishop appears at +17500 after being absent from last week’s published table.
Where the Heisman Value Sits Before Ohio State-Michigan
Smith at roughly -556 asks a bettor to pay for another strong showing before he faces Michigan. The Wolverines just held UCLA to 16 points in a triple-overtime win. A win over Michigan and a big receiving line for Smith are two different asks.
Dampier at +700 prices in at 12.5% and Lopez at +2500 lands at 3.85%. Dampier has the shorter path on price. Lopez offers the larger return, but would still have to pass Smith, Dampier and Mensah in the voting to cash.
For anyone considering Smith, the question is whether to buy before Michigan or risk a shorter number afterward. Another performance like the one in Lincoln leaves little upside in waiting. A quiet afternoon in Columbus could reopen the race.
Lead NHL & NCAAF Editor
Brady is the lead NHL and College Football editor at Sports Betting Dime, where he specializes in betting odds and data-driven analysis. Brady has over 10 years experience working in sports media, with work published by outlets such as ESPN, CBS Sports, Yahoo! Sports and Fox Sports.