Red Sox Updated Win Total Set at 90.5: Analyzing Boston’s New Over/Under at the All-Star Break

By Ryan Bolta in MLB Baseball
Updated: April 8, 2020 at 12:08 pm EDTPublished:

- The Boston Red Sox (49-41) are 3rd in the American League East at the All-Star break
- They have blown 18 of their 36 save opportunities (50%) which is tied for last in the league
- The Red Sox remaining schedule leads you to believe they could make a charge in the 2nd half
The All-Star break is the perfect time to breathe and take a few days to survey the landscape in Major League Baseball. After going through all the numbers there’s a bet that I absolutely love when looking at the American League East win totals.
2019 AL East Win Totals & Odds
Team | Win Total | Odds |
---|---|---|
New York Yankees | 99.5 | O -110 / U -110 |
Boston Red Sox | 90.5 | O -110 / U -110 |
Tampa Bay Rays | 89.5 | O -110 / U -110 |
Toronto Blue Jays | 66.5 | O -110 / U -110 |
Baltimore Orioles | 54.5 | O -110 / U -110 |
*odds taken 7/9
When looking at SBD’s updated 2019 Win Totals Tracker, the Boston Red Sox over stands out to me for three very obvious reasons.
Run Differential Suggests Wins Are Coming
Boston has scored 58 more runs than they’ve allowed this year. That ranks 6th in the American League and should get even higher if the team can improve their bullpen woes (more on that in a minute). As a point of comparison, the Atlanta Braves are +59 this season and they sit 17 games over .500 and hold a 6-game lead in the NL East.
🌟 All-Stars & WS Champs 🌟 pic.twitter.com/7qr5KEbAdK
— Red Sox (@RedSox) July 9, 2019
Now you can’t directly compare teams, especially when they play in different leagues, but a +58 margin suggests that the win total should be closer to Atlanta’s 54 than Boston’s 49.
Bullpen Has Been Boston’s Achilles Heel
The Red Sox bullpen hasn’t been bad, it’s been shockingly awful. They have as many blown saves as they have converted =this season. Let that sink in for a minute. In 36 opportunities they’ve only closed 18 games. The 50% mark is tied for dead last in the league and well behind any other true playoff contender.
Red Sox Reportedly "Surveying" Bullpen Market https://t.co/K2RPwnIynt pic.twitter.com/sEA4j1sfbB
— MLB Trade Rumors (@mlbtraderumors) June 30, 2019
The Red Sox lost Craig Kimbrel off their World Series-winning roster from last year but many of the other arms returned. The issue is they all moved into higher-leverage situations and it hasn’t resulted in success.
President of Baseball Operations Dave Dombrowski has a big enough sample size now to know he has to address this issue. As teams fall from the playoff race, maybe even in their own division, arms should become available and Boston should be ready to pounce.
Remaining Schedule Shapes Up Well For Boston
It’s easy to think that, in a division with the Yankees and Rays, Boston has a lot of tough matchups left. Some deeper digging however and you notice just how friendly this schedule is going forward. Boston plays the Orioles, Blue Jays and Royals a combined 19 times over the final 72 games, good for 26% of their remaining schedule.
Those three teams are a combined 89 games under .500 and should provide ample opportunity for wins and rest for the weary bullpen arms.
Fangraphs projects the Red Sox to win 91 games and, while that would be enough to hit the over, I think they may go even higher with this many cupcake games in the 2nd half.
PICK: Boston Red Sox Over 90.5 wins (-110)

Sports Writer
Ryan has been working at TSN for over eleven years, and is now a lead writer and content producer at That's Hockey. Over the years, he's launched and hosted TSN's first NCAAF podcast, The College Football Show, and been featured on the likes of TSN 1050, Sportscentre, and That's Hockey 2Nite.