Skip to content

Top Home Run Picks for Dinger Tuesday (May 26)

John Hyslop

By John Hyslop in MLB Baseball

Published:


May 23, 2026; Phoenix, Arizona, USA; Arizona Diamondbacks second baseman Ketel Marte (4) celebrates with outfielder Tim Tawa (13) after hitting a two run home run against the Colorado Rockies during the fourth inning at Chase Field. Mandatory Credit: Anna Carrington-Imagn Images
  • We’ve got another full slate of MLB games for Dinger Tuesday, May 26
  • When this happens, we need to find at least three guys we like to go yard and bet them
  • See below for my three best home run plays for today

Hopefully, everyone had a great Memorial Day Weekend because now it’s time to lock in for the dog days of summer. Generally speaking, Memorial Day is the kickoff to the summer, even though summer doesn’t officially start until next month. Temperatures are up, and we’re already seeing a ton of “suns out, guns out” situations, so it’s basically summer. What does that mean for us sports bettors? Two words: Home Runs. As the weather warms, so do Major League hitters. That’s just how they roll. Lucky for us, today is Dinger Tuesday, which means a full slate of games. With all this action, we have to be able to find at least three guys that we know for a fact will go yard tonight. Feels like the move.

Home Run Picks For Tuesday (May 26)

PickOdds
Juan Soto HR+456 (18¢ at Kalshi)
Kyle Schwarber HR+300 (25¢ at Kalshi )
Ketel Marte HR+567 (15¢ at Kalshi)

Each one of the home run picks for today is at least +300, meaning if we bet the same amount on each player and one of them hit a dinger, we would profit.

Putting all three in a long-shot home run parlay at DraftKings generates +10524 odds.

MLB odds as of May 26 at Kalshi. Claim SBD’s exclusive Kalshi promo code.

Tuesday Home Run Pick #1 – Juan Soto Will Start Us Off Right

What we need to get us going is a nice, easy meatball. A guy who is known to hit bombs, being priced like a guy who isn’t really known to hit bombs. Those guys aren’t always easy to find, but we know them when we see them.

One guy who fits that description tonight is Juan Soto.

PitchSoto Barrel Rate vs RHP (L15)Burns EV vs LHB (2026)
Four-seam fastball26.7%85.1 MPH

The haters are going to say that Soto is up against Chase Burns tonight, so he won’t go yard, but whatever. At what point did we start listening to the haters? First off, Burns has already given up seven home runs this season. Of those seven home runs, five have been to lefties. The man will give it up. We’ve all seen him. Now throw in the fact that Burns throws his four-seam fastball to lefties 60% of the time and we’re on to something. Soto rakes that pitch from righties, which makes him a great place to start tonight. Feels easy.

  • The Bet: Juan Soto to Hit a Home Run (+456 at Kalshi)
Prediction Markets
Juan Soto HR Pick (May 26)
Learn more about Prediction Markets
Kalshi
Juan Soto 1+ HR
18%

Tuesday HR Pick #2 – Kyle Schwarber Still Hits Bombs

Now that we’ve got one guy in our pocket, it’s not the time to get complacent. We need to keep our feet firmly pressed on the gas because that’s what the books would do to us if they had the chance. It’s just the nature of the game we play. We actually like it like that.

Lucky for us, Kyle Schwarber is running into a matchup with Randy Vasquez. The rich just get richer.

PitchSchwarber Barrel Rate vs RHP (L10)Vasquez EV vs LHB (2026)
Four-Seam Fastball26.7%90.5 MPH

Here’s the thing: Schwarber is only +266. At some books, I’ve seen him as low as +230. Still, I think there is still value in this thing. We’re matchup hunting, and this looks like a good matchup for Kyle. Basically, any matchup is a good one for Kyle, but especially this one. Vasquez throws seven different pitches, and Schwarber has at least one home run this season versus every one of those pitches from right-handers. Feels right.

  • The Bet: Kyle Schwarber to Hit a Home Run (+300 at Kalshi)
Prediction Markets
Kyle Schwarber HR Pick (May 26)
Learn more about Prediction Markets
Kalshi
Kyle Schwarber 1+ HR
25%

Tuesday HR Pick #3 – Ketel Marte Is Raking

Finally, we’re going to need a guy who is white hot to round this thing out. We’ve already got two thumpers. Why not add a guy who is legit in the zone? It just makes sense. Especially when the guy that is “in the zone” is also a thumper.

We’re talking Ketel Marte in a plus matchup with Tyler Mahle.

PitchMarte Barrel Rate vs RHP (L15)Mahle Barrel Rate vs LHB (2026)
Four-seam Fastball33.3%16%

It took Marte a while to get going, but he’s finally going. Over his last seven games, he’s hit the ball over the fence three times. There were another handful of times where he hit the ball 100+ MPH, but it somehow stayed in play. Tonight, he’s going to see a guy in Mahle that he has owned over his career. I’m not a batter vs pitcher guy, but it’s hard to ignore the 8-12 with two dingers stat line Marte has versus Mahle. My guess is this is not a time Mahle wants to see Marte. Feels right.

  • The Bet: Ketel Marte to Hit a Home Run (+567 at Kalshi)
Prediction Markets
Ketel Marte HR Pick (May 26)
Learn more about Prediction Markets
Kalshi
Ketel Marte 1+ HR
15%

Sign Up for SBD’s Newsletter Now

Did you want the latest sports betting news, analysis, picks, betting trends, and relevant data straight to your inbox? If so, you’ll want to subscribe to SBD’s newsletter now!

John Hyslop

John has spent the past 20+ years betting sports on a daily basis and is considered by many to be a walking sports betting encyclopedia. From obscure player props to sides and totals, if there is an angle, John will find it.

NFL NBA MLB NCAAF NCAAB

Recommended Reading