Joe Douglas Favored to Be New York Jets’ Next GM, Peyton Manning Given 4-1 Odds

By Ryan Bolta in NFL Football
Updated: March 31, 2020 at 4:15 pm EDTPublished:

- The New York Jets continue to search for a new GM after firing Mike Maccagnan
- Peyton Manning is considered by many to be a legitimate candidate despite never holding an NFL front office position
- Eagles VP of Player Personnel Joe Douglas is the favorite thanks to his success helping build a Super Bowl winning roster in Philadelphia
Mike Maccagnan is out as GM of the New York Jets and rumors are swirling over who his replacement will be.
Who Will Be the Next GM of the New York Jets?
Who Will Be the Next GM of the Jets? | Odds |
---|---|
Joe Douglas | +125 |
Champ Kelly | +300 |
Peyton Manning | +400 |
Adam Peters | +800 |
Will McClay | +800 |
Daniel Jeremiah | +900 |
Eliot Wolf | +900 |
Lance Newmark | +1000 |
*Odds taken 05/23/19
Head Coach Adam Gase is part of the search committee tasked with picking the Jets’ new GM and that could be important. He has a relationship with Peyton Manning and that could lead to the former QB getting more of a look than he might deserve. With that in mind, he’s one of two candidates I believe you should zero in on when considering where to lay your money.
Statement from Jets Chairman and CEO Christopher Johnson on Mike Maccagnan. pic.twitter.com/cHWNJzExLp
— New York Jets (@nyjets) May 15, 2019
Could Manning Be the Pick?
Adam Gase was Manning’s former offensive coordinator so there’s no denying their relationship. That could be important with Gase having a clear say on who his successor will be (Gase is acting GM during the search). Could Manning do the job? Why not.
John Elway has had success with the Denver Broncos and provides a great example of a former Hall of Fame QB can thrive in the management arena.
Anyone suggesting it’s a leap for someone who hasn’t been in a front office before is downplaying the fact Manning is clearly a great football mind. He would know more than anyone how to help shape a roster to give second year starter Sam Darnold the best chance to succeed.
Jets are targeting Peyton Manning to fill key front office role, per @ProFootballTalk pic.twitter.com/mfiRgfnIuO
— B/R Gridiron (@brgridiron) May 18, 2019
John Elway has had success with the Denver Broncos and provides a great example of a former Hall of Fame QB can thrive in the management arena. Manning may not be the most natural candidate, but what have the Jets done over the past handful of years that leads you to believe something natural is about to happen?
Joe Douglas is the Leading Candidate
Manning would be a sexy hire, but Philadelphia Eagles VP of Player Personnel Joe Douglas may be the smart one. There is a reason he is the favorite paying only +125, and that’s because many reports have him atop the Jets’ wish list. There’s yet to be any indication the feeling is mutual, but with only 32 GM gigs available in the league, it would be hard to imagine one in a big market like New York coming available and Douglas rejecting an offer.
🎬 LIVE 🎬
Coach Gase speaks to the media during Week 1 of OTAs. https://t.co/aCN74Qem9Z
— New York Jets (@nyjets) May 23, 2019
Douglas is credited with helping build the Eagles roster that won Super Bowl LII. That’s the type of leadership the Jets need to turn this ship around. As much as Manning may be the more entertaining option as an outsider, I believe the smart money goes with the favorite in this case.
Pick: Joe Douglas (+125)

Sports Writer
Ryan has been working at TSN for over eleven years, and is now a lead writer and content producer at That's Hockey. Over the years, he's launched and hosted TSN's first NCAAF podcast, The College Football Show, and been featured on the likes of TSN 1050, Sportscentre, and That's Hockey 2Nite.