Rockies vs Pirates Props & Picks for Skenes vs Lorenzen

• It’s Paul Skenes Day as the Pittsburgh Pirates host the Colorado Rockies
• Will the Pirates dominate the Rockies? Is it a low-scoring game?
• For the answers to those questions, you’ll have to keep scrolling to see the latest picks and odds

---

The Pittsburgh Pirates (22-19) welcome the Colorado Rockies (16-25) to PNC Park on Tuesday, May 12, 2026. First pitch is scheduled for 6:40 PM ET.

These clubs are opening a new series tonight. The Pirates enter as a heavy home favorite following a 1-0 victory over the Cincinnati Reds. Conversely, the Rockies arrive as a road underdog, reeling from a 6-0 shutout loss to the Philadelphia Phillies.

I will be focusing on the mound as Pirates starter Paul Skenes goes head-to-head with Rockies veteran Michael Lorenzen. Skenes is backed by a lineup featuring Marcell Ozuna and Bryan Reynolds, setting the stage for a distinct betting landscape against a struggling Rockies roster.

Rockies vs Pirates Picks, Predictions, and Best Bets

Pick 1: Under 7.5 Runs (-110 at Caesars Sportsbook)

Handicapping this game comes down to a statistical mismatch on the mound. I’m targeting the Under 7.5 runs for my primary prediction. The Pirates’ pitching staff owns a collective 3.73 ERA, and Skenes has proven he can consistently suppress opposing lineups.

While the Pirates’ offense (.727 team OPS) should find success against Lorenzen, they are unlikely to push the game over the total single-handedly. My analysis shows the Rockies lack the exit velocity and firepower necessary to contribute to a high-scoring affair.

Pick 2: Paul Skenes over 7.5 strikeouts (-120 at DraftKings)

I’m backing Paul Skenes Over 7.5 Pitcher Strikeouts. He is striking out batters at a rate of 9.86 per nine innings. Given the Rockies’ overall struggles at the plate, Skenes should have plenty of opportunities to rack up punchouts and clear this number.

Odds as of May 12, 2026, at 2:55 PM ET from Caesars Sportsbook, and DraftKings

Michael Lorenzen vs Paul Skenes

The pitching matchup heavily favors the home team. Skenes owns a 2.36 ERA and an underlying 2.81 FIP. He excels at missing bats while displaying strong command (1.50 BB/9).

Opponents are managing a .156 batting average against him. His 0.71 WHIP highlights his ability to keep traffic off the basepaths entirely, limiting RBI opportunities. Always consult our MLB batter vs pitcher stats when you’re building your MLB parlays.

Lorenzen’s season has been a struggle. He carries a 7.11 ERA and a 5.27 FIP into Tuesday’s contest. He has allowed a .363 opponent batting average. His 1.95 WHIP means nearly two baserunners reach per inning, a difficult hurdle to overcome.

Team Statistics Comparison

To understand the gap between these two rosters, I analyzed their respective splits. The numbers validate the betting markets favoring the Pirates so heavily.

At PNC Park, the Pirates lead all of baseball with a .283 home batting average. They sit second in both home OPS (.814) and runs scored per game (5.85).

The Rockies have struggled outside of Coors Field. They rank tied for 20th in road run production (3.95 per game) and 28th in average exit velocity (86.9 mph). They possess the capability on the basepaths, ranking third in away stolen bases per game (1.09), but their .679 road OPS limits those opportunities.

 

Rockies vs Pirates Odds

Odds as of May 12, 2026, at 2:55 PM ET from BetMGM, bet365, and Caesars Sportsbook,

The Pirates enter Tuesday’s contest as a massive home favorite on the moneyline at -305. Removing the vig from these moneyline odds implies a 75.31% win probability for the Pirates and a 30.30% chance for the Rockies.

Even on the runline, MLB odds demand significant juice (-125) to back the Pirates to win by multiple runs. When betting markets opened, the runline was established at Pirates -1.5 (-125) and Rockies +1.5 (+105). Since then, a surge in action has caused the price to surge further toward the home team.

The opening total was set at 7.5 runs, with the Under favored at -115. The baseline total remains static, but the juice has equalized to -110 on both sides.

Rockies vs Pirates Betting Trends and Splits

I always review situational trends before finalizing my card. The Pirates have handled expectations well this season, posting a 16-8 (66.7%) record when favored. Over their last 10 games, they are 5-1 (83.3%) as the favorite.

The Rockies have been a risky bet all year. They enter this series having won just 20.0% of their last 10 games (2-8 overall). Operating strictly as underdogs over that span, they failed to overcome the odds, posting a 2-8 (20.0%) record in that role. The Over has hit in 70.0% of the Rockies’ last 10 matchups.

The MLB public betting percentages split shows action skewed heavily in one direction. A massive 90% of the moneyline tickets are backing the Pirates. However, the handle paints a slightly more balanced picture. The Pirates command 77% of the money, while the Rockies draw 23% of the handle on just 10% of the tickets.

The total market presents a fascinating dynamic. Bettors are heavily backing a high-scoring affair, with 84% of tickets and 79% of the money on the Over. By picking the Under, I am taking a contrarian stance rooted in Skenes’ run prevention metrics rather than following the public money.

Rockies vs Pirates Injury Report

Both clubs are dealing with notable absences, though the Rockies shoulder a heavier burden.

For the Rockies, the most glaring absence is designated hitter Kris Bryant. Without his presence, an already weak road offense loses an established power bat. The sheer number of injured pitchers also compromises their bullpen depth. These types of injuries could affect the MLB starting pitchers and lineups.

The Pirates enter with their core lineup intact. While Jake Mangum is out, their primary run producers are fully healthy. The absences of Chris Devenski and Jared Jones thin out the pitching staff, but this will have minimal impact on tonight’s game script if Skenes pitches deep into his start.