Yankees vs Orioles Expert Picks & Predictions for May 13

• New York enters as a heavy road favorite against a struggling Baltimore roster.
• Max Fried provides a massive pitching advantage over Kyle Bradish on the mound.
• I am targeting Aaron Judge to record an RBI in this divisional matchup.

---

The New York Yankees (27-16) continue their series against the Baltimore Orioles (19-24) on May 13, 2026, at 1:05 PM ET at Oriole Park at Camden Yards. Coming off a decisive 6-2 victory over Baltimore in their previous contest, New York capitalized on a five-run third inning powered by a Trent Grisham three-run home run. Meanwhile, the Orioles mustered just two runs on six hits as Trevor Rogers returned from the IL.

I will break down the analytical angles for this American League East clash, exploring the spread, run total, and moneyline to help you find the best value on the board.

Yankees vs Orioles Picks & Predictions

• Yankees Moneyline (-186, FanDuel)

I am backing New York to win outright on the moneyline. The Yankees possess a massive statistical advantage on both sides of the ball. Their pitching staff is suffocating opponents, boasting a 3.12 team ERA and a 1.14 WHIP. Max Fried anchors that success, holding opposing hitters to a microscopic .185 batting average. Against an Orioles lineup lacking key power bats, Fried is in a great spot to dominate.

The Yankees are second favorites in 2026 World Series odds for good reason, leading the AL by a sizable margin. Only the Dodgers have shorter odds than the Bronx Bombers.

• Over 8.5 Runs (-118, BetMGM)

I also like the over in this game. Baltimore gives up entirely too much traffic on the basepaths. Kyle Bradish takes the mound with a 4.83 ERA and a concerning 1.66 WHIP. The Orioles have already surrendered 230 runs on the year en route to an ERA+ of 88. Given New York’s offensive profile (5.2 runs per game), I expect the visitors to do the heavy lifting in pushing this game over the total.

• Aaron Judge to Record an RBI (+110, FanDuel)

My favorite player prop for this matchup is Aaron Judge to record an RBI. While Judge has yet to drive in a run in this series, he has three hits and two walks thus far. Judge leads the AL with 16 home runs, contributing to his second-place tally of 30 runs batted in. Judge has struggled against Bradish (1-for-11, zero RBI), but today is a great opportunity to buck that trend.

Max Fried vs Kyle Bradish Matchup

Fried has been a dominant force at the front of the rotation. The left-hander excels at limiting hard contact and keeping runners off the bases entirely. His 2.73 FIP indicates his elite run prevention is sustainable over the long haul. Furthermore, Fried provides deep outings, averaging 6.52 innings per start over his nine starts, which perfectly preserves the bullpen.

Bradish, conversely, has struggled mightily. Traffic on the basepaths has been his primary issue. While he possesses swing-and-miss stuff with a 9.88 K/9 rate, his severe command issues negate those strikeouts. Handing out free passes at a clip of 4.83 walks per nine innings, Bradish routinely sets the table for opposing offenses and averages just 5.12 innings per start.

Betting Trends

• New York has won 62.8% of its games overall this season.
• The Under has cashed in 60.0% of New York’s last 10 matchups.
• Baltimore has won just 31.6% of its games as the betting underdog.
• The Under has hit in 60.0% of Baltimore’s last 10 games.

Yankees vs Orioles Odds

The Yankees are favored to take this game (and the series), sitting at -195 odds on the moneyline and -115 odds on a -1.5 runline. The underdog Orioles are listed at +162 on the moneyline at +1.5 on the runline (-105 odds).

The total is set at 8.5 runs. Over bettors should take over 8.5 runs at -120 odds. Under bettors should take under 8.5 runs at +100 odds.

Odds as of May 13, 2026, at 10:00 AM ET from Caesars Sportsbook.

Yankees vs Orioles Betting Splits

When breaking down the betting markets, comparing where the public places their tickets versus where the actual money flows offers valuable insight.

For the moneyline market, 92.0% of the tickets and a massive 96.3% of the money are riding on New York. Bettors are showing zero hesitation in fading Bradish. Since both the ticket count and handle overwhelmingly favor the favorites, there is no sharp versus public divide to monitor here.

The action on the game’s total tells a similar story. While the ticket split is slightly more balanced with 58.8% taking the over, a commanding 73.8% of the total financial stake backs a high-scoring affair. This heavier cash percentage aligns perfectly with my official prediction of taking the over in this contest.

As always, it is useful to see the MLB public betting splits to see where the public aligns on a given game.

Yankees vs Orioles Injury Reports

Baltimore is navigating a significant injury crisis. Missing elite late-inning relievers severely compromises their bullpen, making it difficult to close out tight games. The absence of reliable starters places immense pressure on pitchers like Bradish to eat innings. Offensively, missing key infield depth completely fractures their run production capabilities. Jackson Holliday has still yet to return from his hamate injury.

For New York, losing the sheer power of Giancarlo Stanton hurts, but their lineup remains potent enough to mask these absences. Judge continues to produce at an elite level, absorbing the loss in the middle of the order. The loss of Gerrit Cole would normally derail a pitching staff, but Fried has seamlessly stepped up as the rotation’s anchor. Even without Cole, the Yankees’ duo of Fried and Cam Schlittler is as good as it gets in MLB.