Reds vs Mets Picks, Predictions & Props to Bet (May 26)

• Cincinnati continues its series against New York following a 7-2 victory on Monday
• Reds ace Chase Burns brings a 1.83 ERA to the mound in this Reds vs Mets matchup
• I am backing Cincinnati on the moneyline (-116) against a depleted New York roster

---

The road favorite Cincinnati Reds (27-25) and home underdog New York Mets (22-31) continue their series under the lights at Citi Field on May 26, 2026, at 7:10 PM EST. Cincinnati enters this matchup with momentum after a decisive 7-2 victory over New York yesterday. The Reds broke the game open with a massive four-run fourth inning, utilizing key home runs from JJ Bleday and Tyler Stephenson.

The Mets will look to bounce back, though their offense has been quiet outside of a Marcus Semien home run. As the series rolls on, I am evaluating an intriguing spot for a New York lineup missing key pieces. They face highly touted Cincinnati probable starter Chase Burns. In this breakdown, I will analyze the pitching mismatch, identify critical offensive trends, and provide my best betting angles for this showdown.

Reds vs Mets Predictions and Best Bets

When evaluating the outlook for this matchup, the starting pitching discrepancy immediately jumps off the page. The Reds are sending right-hander Chase Burns to the mound. He has been spectacular during the 2026 campaign. Over 59.0 innings pitched, Burns boasts a microscopic 1.83 ERA and a 0.95 WHIP. He is holding opposing batters to a dismal .183 average.

Given that the Mets currently feature an uninspiring .643 team OPS and are operating with a “TBD” starting pitcher, the edge heavily favors the visitors. New York will likely struggle to string together consecutive base hits against Burns, making a lower-scoring affair highly probable. Because of this massive pitching advantage, my official play is the Reds Moneyline (-116 at FanDuel).

The most compelling betting value on the board comes in the prop market. My favorite player prop is Chase Burns Over 6.5 Strikeouts (+100 on FanDuel). Burns has been missing bats at an elite clip all season, generating 9.76 strikeouts per nine innings, and he should be in line for another favorable matchup since the Mets have been struggling on offense all season long.

Getting even money on him to record seven or more punchouts is a fantastic position. He faces a Mets lineup that has already amassed 434 strikeouts as a team, and while that’s the 11th-best mark in the majors, that won’t matter much. With New York struggling to produce runs and Burns working deep into games, he should have ample opportunities to clear this threshold.

Chase Burns vs TBD

Without a traditional starter lined up, New York will likely have to piece together 27 outs from a relief corps that will have little margin for error. Burns carries an exceptional 6-1 record alongside his stifling 1.83 ERA.

Over his last 10 appearances, Burns has provided remarkable consistency, averaging 5.90 innings per start. His overwhelming swing-and-miss stuff makes him exceptionally difficult to square up. I expect him to dictate the pace of this game from the first at-bat.

Reds vs Mets Team Stats Comparison

When analyzing how these two teams stack up, several mismatches become glaringly apparent. New York has consistently failed to capitalize on its home-field advantage. They rank an abysmal 26th in the league with a .658 OPS in front of their home crowd, the fifth-worst mark in MLB. Despite boasting hard-hitting active stars like Semien and Bo Bichette, they struggle to translate raw contact into sustained run production.

Conversely, Cincinnati presents a dynamic attack on the road. While their .231 away batting average is modest and ranks 18th in the majors, they excel at manufacturing runs. Cincinnati is stealing 0.93 bases per game in away contests, ranking seventh in the majors.

This aggressive baserunning is spearheaded by electrifying shortstop Elly De La Cruz. Given the heavy bullpen usage expected from New York, De La Cruz will have ample opportunity to exploit favorable base-stealing situations. I highly recommend looking at his stolen base props tonight.

Reds vs Mets Odds and Betting Splits

Odds as of May 26, 2026, at 0:18 AM ET from FanDuel.

Cincinnati enters this matchup as a slight road favorite at -116 on the moneyline. This reflects the sizable starting pitching advantage they hold with Burns on the mound. Conversely, New York sits at near even-money as a home underdog. Oddsmakers lack confidence given the unannounced starting pitcher and recent offensive woes at Citi Field. Both the opening spread of 1.5 runs and the opening total of 7.5 runs have remained completely unchanged since the markets first opened.

A dive into the betting splits reveals exactly where the big money is leaning, according to our MLB public data page. The moneyline market shows decisive support for the visitors. Currently, Cincinnati commands 65.8% of the betting tickets, but an overwhelming 88.9% of the overall money. This massive concentration aligns perfectly with my prediction to back the moneyline favorite.

The runline presents a fascinating divergence. While the tickets are relatively split, a staggering 92.5% of the runline money is pouring in on Cincinnati (-1.5).

In the total market, bettors expect offensive fireworks despite the low 7.5-run projection. The Over is dominating, garnering 69.3% of the betting tickets and 73.4% of the overall money. Given Burns’ elite ability to suppress opposing lineups, an Under scenario remains the more logical angle to me.

Here are a few situational trends to consider before locking in your wagers:

• Cincinnati has hit the Over in 60.4% of its games this season.
• New York has a 4-11 record (26.7% win percentage) when listed as the underdog in 2026.
• The Mets’ offense has hit the Over in only 38.9% of their games this season.

Reds vs Mets Injury Report

The injury report is a crucial piece of the puzzle for tonight’s matchup. It paints a grim picture for New York. With a staggering 15 players currently managing active injuries, their roster depth is being pushed to its absolute limits. The most pressing concern is the health of superstar outfielder Juan Soto. Soto was sidelined during the series opener due to an illness. If he is unable to suit up, an already struggling offense loses its most dangerous bat.

Furthermore, New York is already navigating life without foundational pieces like shortstop Francisco Lindor and outfielder Luis Robert Jr. These offensive absences heavily impact the game plan. Without this collective plate discipline, it will be exceedingly difficult to string together sustained rallies against Burns. Conversely, Cincinnati is entering this contest in much better shape regarding their everyday lineup.