Skip to content

Thursday NHL Player Props: Shots on Goal & Anytime Goalscorer Picks (Nov. 19)

Eric Rosales

By Eric Rosales in NHL Hockey

Published:


Auston Matthews waits for faceoff
Oct 28, 2026; Seattle, Washington, USA; Toronto Maple Leafs forward Auston Matthews (34) is pictured during a game against the Seattle Kraken at Climate Pledge Arena. Mandatory Credit: Stephen Brashear-Imagn Images
  • I’ve got three NHL player props for Thursday’s slate
  • Two high-volume shooters and one goalscorer headline my card
  • See my NHL player props and best bets below

My Thursday NHL player props focus on shots on goal and anytime goalscorers across three matchups. Kings at Maple Leafs starts the card at 7pm ET, followed by Oilers at Lightning at 7:30 pm and Stars at Golden Knights at 10pm.

Auston Matthews comes off a six-shot outing, while Connor McDavid’s heavy workload keeps him in the conversation every night. Jason Robertson supplies the goalscorer angle in a rematch with Vegas after creating chances in Tuesday’s meeting.

All three prices come from Novig, a prediction exchange where you buy contracts that pay out if the prop hits. Here are my NHL player props for Thursday.

Thursday NHL Player Prop Odds

PlayerMatchupPropNovig Buy Price
Auston MatthewsLAK at TOROver 3.5 Shots on Goal46.5¢
Connor McDavidEDM at TBOver 2.5 Shots on Goal56¢
Jason RobertsonDAL at VGKAnytime Goalscorer38¢

These Thursday NHL player prop odds are Novig buy prices for Nov. 19. Each contract pays $1 if the prop hits, so a 46.5¢ buy works out to about +115 and a 46.5% implied chance before fees. McDavid’s 56¢ price is roughly -127, and Robertson’s 38¢ is about +163. Any applicable fees reduce the net return; check the order details before buying.

New to the exchange? Check our Novig promo code page, or compare other NHL betting apps before you play.

Best NHL Player Props for Thursday

My best NHL player props for Thursday pair two shots-on-goal picks with a goalscorer bet. I favor repeatable opportunities and ice time over chasing a player simply because he scored in his last game.

NHL Prop Pick #1: Auston Matthews Over 3.5 Shots on Goal

  • Pick: Auston Matthews Over 3.5 Shots on Goal

My Thursday NHL prop picks start with Matthews over 3.5 shots on goal against Los Angeles. He has 72 shots in 23 games and has recorded four or more in 10 of them, so recent form matters more to this pick than his full-season hit rate. The 46.5% implied chance sits a bit above that 43% season rate, which means I’m leaning on his recent volume rather than claiming a big edge.

Matthews put six shots on goal in Chicago on Tuesday and has reached four or more in three of his last five games. The Kings allow 27.5 shots per game, and Toronto’s power play converts at 25.4%. LA’s 68.3% penalty kill doesn’t guarantee Matthews more shots, but any extra power-play time gives him more chances to shoot.

NHL Prop Pick #2: Connor McDavid Over 2.5 Shots on Goal

  • Pick: Connor McDavid Over 2.5 Shots on Goal

Next up, I’m backing McDavid over 2.5 shots on goal in Tampa. He has 64 shots in 23 games and has hit three or more in 14 of them, about 61% of the time. At 56¢, the market’s implied chance is a bit below that season rate, though a season hit rate isn’t a forecast.

Over his last five games, he’s posted 2, 4, 3, 2 and 4 shots, clearing this number three times while logging more than 21 minutes in each game. This is no soft matchup: Tampa Bay allows only 25.1 shots per game and Edmonton averages 24.8. I’m trusting his workload to get him to three.

NHL Prop Pick #3: Jason Robertson Anytime Goalscorer

  • Pick: Jason Robertson Anytime Goalscorer

I’m wrapping up with Robertson as an anytime goalscorer in Vegas. He has 10 goals this season, but they’ve come in seven of his 21 games, so he scores in about a third of his outings. The 38¢ price asks a little more than that, which means I’m buying his shot volume as much as his finishing.

That volume is steady. Robertson has 68 shots and has put three or more on goal in 16 of 21 games. In Tuesday’s game in Vegas, he had three shots and two assists in 23:43 but didn’t score. Within his last five games, he scored against San Jose and Florida and fired five shots against Buffalo. Vegas allows 2.83 goals per game, and Dallas’ 23.5% power play gives him another route to a goal.

Eric Rosales
Eric Rosales

Sports Writer & Editor

Having worked in and around sports since 1997, Eric is truly a knowledgeable expert. The two-time journalism grad specializes in all things NBA and NFL. From TSN.ca to CTV's Olympic Broadcast Consortium, Eric's work has appeared in local and national publications alike.

NFL NBA

Recommended Reading