2025-26 NFL Coach of the Year Odds Tracker

• Get the latest odds to win the 2025-26 NFL Coach of the Year award
• Shane Steichen is the NFL COY favorite
• Track how the NFL COY odds change throughout the course of the 2025-26 NFL season

The Associated Press has been handing out an NFL Coach of the Year award since 1957. Below you’ll find the odds to win the 2025-26 NFL COY award. The graphs below were generated by averaging the odds from multiple sportsbooks.

2025-26 NFL Coach of the Year Award Odds & Favorites

Top 8 Top 16 All

The NFL Coach of the Year award is not always awarded to the best head coach in the league. Often, it goes to the coach who turned around a bad team early in his tenure, or one whose team still won a lot of games while playing without some of their stars.

It’s hard to predict which coaches will see their teams suffer through some bad injury luck, but it is easy to identify the candidates to turn around bad or underachieving teams. This is why we saw Ben Johnson, who took over a Bears team who greatly underachieved last season, listed as the early favorite to win NFL COY, and have coaches like Mike Vrabel, who took over a bad Patriots team, Pete Carroll, who is in his first year as the Raiders head coach, and Liam Coen, who took on an underachieving Jaguars team, all listed with short odds prior to kickoff.

However, things have not gone well for Johnson in Chicago so far and he has tumbled down the board. We have seen Shane Steichen rise up and become the new favorite after Week 2.

NFL COY Odds

*We are experiencing some troubles with our BetMGM NFL Coach of the Year odds. Please allow us some time to fix things up!

Shane Steichen is given the best odds to win the 2025-26 NFL Coach of the Year award. Steichen’s odds are listed at +700, which implies he has a 12.5% chance to win the award. If you bet $20 on the Colts’ head coach, your potential profit would be $140 while returning $160.

The top NFL Coach of the Year contenders after Week 2 are:

1. Shane Steichen, Colts (+700 consensus odds)
2. Matt LaFleur, Packers (+825)
3. Jonathan Gannon, Cardinals (+925)
4. Jim Harbaugh, Chargers (+950)
5. Mike Vrabel, Patriots (+1350)

The coaches making the most notable rise up the NFL COY odds after Week 2 are:

• Shane Steichen: the Colts’ head coach saw his odds improve from +1200 to +700 after beating the Broncos in Week 2. Steichen had Daniel Jones carving up Denver’s defense through the air for 316 yards and a touchdown. The odds improvement resulted in Steichen becoming the new favorite.
• Matt LaFleur: after Green Bay beat up on the Commanders in Week 2, LaFlaur’s odds improved from +1400 to +825, giving him the second-best odds on the board.

And the coaches who saw their odds fall most notably include:

• Ben Johnson: after opening as the favorite and spending most of the offseason neck-and-neck with Mike Vrabel, Bears head coach Ben Johnson has become an afterthought in the odds after Week 2. Chicago was embarrassed by the Lions and Johnson’s odds faded from +900 to +3250 following the bad loss.
• Liam Cohen: the Jags head coach entered Week 2 as the favorite, but a bad loss to the Bengals, where Joe Burrow didn’t even play the majority of the game, saw his odds fade from +650 to +1400.

*NFL Coach of the Year odds are updated every 15 minutes in the table above, surfacing up the best odds available from DraftKings, FanDuel, and other top sportsbooks. If you’re new to DraftKings, be sure to check out the best DraftKings promo codes before signing up.

For more great bonuses, check out our BetMGM promo code and FanDuel Sportsbook promo code pages. While you’re at it, take a peek at our excellent Bet365 bonus code page that highlights welcome offers from one of the top new sportsbooks in North America.

Here are some more notes on the movement we have seen:

• [September 16] Shane Steichen took over as the new favorite after beating the Broncos, and helping Daniel Jones throw for 316 yards against what was believed to be a stingy Denver defense.
• [September 9] Liam Cohen became the new favorite to win Coach of the Year after his Jaguars put together a convincing win over the Panthers in Week 1.
• [August 29] Ben Johnson reclaimed the best odds to win Coach of the Year after the Bears’ starting offense put together some encouraging drives during the preseason.
• [August 15] Bettors had to be appreciating Jonathan Gannon, as the Cardinals’ coach saw his odds improve from an average of +2500 in late-June to +1700 in mid-August.
• [July 22] Mike Vrabel overtook Ben Johnson as the favorite to win NFL Coach of the Year. Neither saw their odds move much at this time, and it was likely just the result of money coming in on Vrabel.
• [March 14] After the Bears added three new starting offensive linemen during free agency, acquiring two of them via trades, as well as bolstering the interior of their defense, Ben Johnson’s NFL Coach of the Year odds improved from +700 to +550.
• [March 7] Pete Carroll was already among the COY favorites prior to the Raiders acquiring Geno Smith, but most sportsbooks did not adjust his odds after the trade. ESPN Bet, however, quickly moved Carroll from +1400 to +1000 after the former Seahawks head coach was reunited with his quarterback.
• [February 12] The opening 2025-26 NFL Coach of the Year odds favor Ben Johnson, who is a first-time head coach and accepted the Bears job. Sportsbooks obviously like the talent Johnson is inheriting in Chicago, and understand he would be a front-runner in the eyes of the voters if he was able to get Caleb Williams going after a rough rookie season.

Looking for the latest NFL odds? – Get current spreads, totals, and moneyline odds for all upcoming games this week here.

AFC vs NFC

AFC NFC

A coach from the AFC has won NFL COY in four of the last six seasons.

Odds for Past Winners

Since 1991, all but one NFL Coach of the Year winner has led their team to at least ten wins in taking home the honor. The lone winner without ten wins was Brian Daboll three seasons ago, whose Giants only went 9-7-1. Daboll’s turnaround was still significant enough, as he took over a team that went 4-13 the previous season and made a QB who had firmly been labeled a bust look very serviceable.

The only other notable from that streak above is Bruce Arians, who led the Colts to a 9-3 record as head coach after taking over for Chuck Pagano after he stepped away for health reasons. The Colts did still win 11 games, though.

Past Coach of the Year Winners

The 2021-22 NFL season was the first time we saw the regular season schedule expanded to 18 weeks, with each team playing 17 games. This is why you see the extra game in all the COY winners since that season.

We have not seen a coach win the honor in back-to-back years since Joe Gibbs in 1982 and 1983.

Archived NFL Coach of the Year odds:

• 2024
• 2023
• 2022
• 2021
• 2020
• 2019