Wichita State vs Tulsa Picks, Predictions & Odds for NIT

• Tulsa is a 3.5 point favorite over Wichita State in the NIT quarter-final
• An elite defensive profile gives bettors a massive edge on the Under
• I uncovered a highly lucrative +460 halftime/fulltime prop bet for this clash

The postseason heats up as the Tulsa Golden Hurricane (28-7, 13-5 American) host the Wichita State Shockers (24-11, 13-5 American) in a high-stakes NIT Quarterfinal clash. This tilt marks an incredibly rare fourth meeting between these historic conference rivals in just 52 days (the Shockers have won two of three). Tip-off is scheduled for 7:00 PM ET on Tuesday, March 24, 2026, at the Donald W Reynolds Center in Tulsa, OK, with broadcast coverage on ESPN2.

Tulsa steps onto their home floor as the betting favorite, but they are limping into this affair with their leading scorer, David Green, sidelined by a shoulder injury. Conversely, the Shockers are an underdog riding a massive wave of momentum. The visitors have won nine of ten, led by All-Conference standout Kenyon Giles, who recently racked up 27 points against the Golden Hurricane in the AAC Tournament.

Tulsa vs Wichita State Predictions

Before diving into my official predictions, here is a quick look at how these two programs stack up statistically. Also, don’t forget to take a gander at the March Madness championship odds for the main tournament.

The Pick: Wichita State +3.5 (-110 at Caesars)

Caesars originally opened this spread at +4.5, but early sharp handle quickly hammered that number down a full point. When respected money moves the markers off a key dead zone, I pay close attention. Checking numbers across the market, including spots like theScore Bet, taking the points offers the ultimate leverage piece.

Wichita State boasts a blistering 9-1 straight-up record in their last ten games, and historically, they are a highly-profitable 7-2 against the spread as an NIT underdog. Furthermore, the Shockers already proved they can handle Tulsa’s pressure, dispatching them 81-68 just over a week ago behind Giles’ 27-point barrage. With the Golden Hurricane missing Green’s offensive firepower, backing the road underdog is my preferred play.

The Pick: Under 152.5 (-110 at FanDuel)

This total has held completely firm since opening, and the matchup dynamics scream Under. Tulsa averages 85.4 points per game, but removing Green from the equation severely handicaps their half-court execution. On the flip side, Wichita State specializes in dragging opponents into the mud, allowing just 70.4 points per contest. Postseason tracks are notoriously diabolical for offensive rhythm, and familiarity breeds defensive success—especially in a fourth meeting. I fully expect a grind-it-out affair, keeping this well beneath the projected total.

Best Prop Bet Edge: Halftime/Fulltime – Away/Away (+460)

The most glaring betting edge comes from the Halftime/Fulltime market. In a fascinating pricing anomaly, oddsmakers list the away/away outcome (Wichita State leading at half and winning the game) at +460, which is inexplicably shorter than the home/home outcome (+600). Despite Tulsa being the outright favorite, the prop market is heavily respecting a wire-to-wire road upset.

Tulsa vs Wichita State Best Odds (Spread, Moneyline & Total)

• Moneyline: Tulsa -180 | Wichita State +152
• Spread: Tulsa -3.5 (-110) | Wichita State +3.5 (-110)
• Total: Over 152.5 (-110) | Under 152.5 (-110)

Odds as of March 24, 2026, at 11:15 AM ET from Caesars Sportsbook

CAESARS SPORTSBOOK

Bet $1 & Double Your Winnings on Your Next 10 Wagers!

LOCK IN PROMO

CODE: SBDDYW

CODE: SBDDYW

SIGNUP PROMO

DOUBLE YOUR
WINNINGS

ON YOUR NEXT 10 WAGERS!

CLAIM OFFER

Looking at the current board, oddsmakers have positioned Tulsa as a moderate home favorite. By stripping out the sportsbook’s vig (the built-in house edge of roughly 3.97%), my calculations reveal a true implied win probability of 61.83% for the Golden Hurricane and 38.17% for the Shockers.

If you are looking to place a straight $20 bet on favored Tulsa at -180, you would net a profit of $11.11, yielding a total payout of $31.11 if they defend their home court. Conversely, dropping that same $20 wager on underdog Wichita State at +152 offers a much more lucrative return. If they successfully pull off the outright road upset, that ticket nets $30.40 in profit for a total payout of $50.40.

Tulsa vs Wichita State Betting Splits

Spread: In the spread market, the action firmly aligns with my recommended pick of the Shockers +3.5. The road underdog is drawing 67.48% of the betting slips, backed by 64.83% of the total spread handle.

Moneyline: The moneyline, however, paints an entirely different and fascinating picture. The casual betting public is rushing to the window to back the favorite, with an overwhelming 87.22% of all moneyline tickets placed on Tulsa. Yet, a closer look reveals a drastic divide: despite taking less than 13% of the tickets, Wichita State has attracted the majority of the moneyline stake at 52.21%.

When larger, more valuable wagers pull the money percentage toward the underdog against an avalanche of public tickets, it signals that bigger bankrolls see serious outright upset potential.

Total: Finally, my official total prediction completely fades the lopsided public narrative. Bettors are pounding the Over in this matchup, with 86.91% of the tickets and an enormous 87.61% of the total stake expecting a high-scoring affair. By recommending the Under 152.5, I am taking a risky stance. Riding the Under provides excellent leverage against a one-sided market expecting a track meet.