Skip to content

Cardinals vs Dodgers Best Bets & Props to Bet

By Michael Schwartz in MLB Baseball

Published:


Aug 5, 2025; Los Angeles, California, USA; Los Angeles Dodgers shortstop Mookie Betts (50) celebrates after hitting a double during the third inning against the St. Louis Cardinals at Dodger Stadium. Mandatory Credit: William Liang-Imagn Images
  • Jordan Walker brings a hot bat against a low-strikeout pitcher.
  • Mookie Betts offers great value to clear his total bases prop.
  • Michael McGreevy profiles well for an under on his strikeout line.

The Los Angeles Dodgers (82-55) host the St. Louis Cardinals (68-70) tonight for a late-night clash at Dodger Stadium. First pitch is scheduled for 10:10 PM ET. The Dodgers sit near the top of the league standings with an impressive home record, while the Cardinals will lean on the potent bats of standout hitters to pull off a road upset.

In researching the pitching profiles, this matchup provides excellent opportunities for sports bettors. Focusing on recent offensive production and season-long metrics offers my favorite path to value tonight.

MLB Player Prop Picks for Cardinals vs Dodgers

Analyzing recent offensive production and season-long pitching profiles offers the best path to value. You can start betting at Caesars now to wager on the action once the markets go live. Here are my three standout player prop picks for tonight’s game.

Jordan Walker Over 1.5 Total Bases (+135 at Caesars)

Jordan Walker brings excellent momentum to the plate this evening, and this is the most aggressive of my three recommendations. Over his last 10 games, Walker is hitting .250 with a .425 slugging percentage, slugging two home runs and averaging 1.000 base hit per game. Those numbers are not dominant on their own, but the combination of recent power, a plus-money price, and a favorable pitching matchup makes this a worthwhile upside play.

For a total-bases prop, one extra-base gets him over the hump: a double, triple, or home run puts Walker over 1.5 total bases.

Walker faces Eric Lauer, who enters with a 3.783 ERA, a 1.145 WHIP, and a low 5.74 K/9. Lauer’s inability to generate consistent swings and misses sets up well for Walker to find a gap. A pitcher who does not consistently finish at-bats with strikeouts gives opposing hitters more opportunities to put the ball in play, and that is especially important for a young hitter whose best path to this prop may be hard contact rather than a string of walks.

He also benefits from the game environment at Dodger Stadium, where St. Louis should have opportunities to see multiple trips through the batting order if the Cardinals can keep the game competitive.

There is clear risk here though. Walker’s .250 average over the last 10 games means that a single hit is far from guaranteed, and the 1.5-total-bases threshold generally requires either two hits or one extra-base knock. That explains why the market is offering plus money.

Still, the price compensates us for the volatility, while Lauer’s modest strikeout rate gives Walker a reasonable chance to create damage when he does make contact. Despite the math favoring the under, Walker’s current trajectory and Lauer’s pitch-to-contact style provide actionable value for a plus-money payout.

Mookie Betts Over 1.5 Total Bases (-115 at BetMGM)

Mookie Betts remains an elite target based on his recent form and is the more reliable batting prop on this card. The dynamic outfielder boasts a .300 batting average, a .391 on-base percentage, and an .816 OPS over his previous 10 games, averaging 1.200 hits in that span.

That profile matters because Betts does not need to rely on one specific outcome. He can clear this number with two singles, a single and a double, a triple, or one home run, and his ability to reach base consistently gives him multiple ways to stay involved in the game.

Betts matches up against Michael McGreevy, who holds a respectable 3.86 ERA this season but a modest 6.20 K/9. McGreevy’s pitch-to-contact profile limits his margin for error against a disciplined batter. When a starter is not piling up strikeouts, quality hitters can extend plate appearances, force the pitcher into the zone, and create more opportunities for hard contact.

Betts’ combination of patience and bat-to-ball skill is well suited to that type of matchup. Even if he does not produce a home run, two well-placed balls in play can be enough to cash the over.

The main concern is the price. At -115, Betts is not being offered as a long-shot value play, so the wager depends on his recent production carrying into this matchup. Total bases can also be sensitive to lineup context and game flow; a blowout or an early pitching change could alter the number of plate appearances he receives.

Nevertheless, the Dodgers’ home setting and Betts’ recent .300 average provide a strong foundation. To back this bet, claim your BetMGM promo now. I expect Betts to continue his steady production and cash this ticket.

Michael McGreevy Under 4.5 Strikeouts (-130 at bet365)

Fading McGreevy in the strikeout market is a logical play because the matchup and his season profile point in the same direction. The Cardinals’ starter holds a 1.25 WHIP, but his 6.20 K/9 highlights a heavy reliance on defensive outs rather than missed bats. That distinction is important against Los Angeles.

The Dodgers generally feature a deep lineup capable of making contact throughout the order, which can force McGreevy to work through innings without accumulating the strikeouts needed to reach five.

McGreevy is averaging just 5.47 innings per start, so he rarely pitches deep enough to accumulate high strikeout totals. Even a solid five-inning outing would require him to strike out nearly one batter per inning to beat this prop, a demanding pace given his season-long rate.

If the Dodgers build an early lead or drive up his pitch count with long at-bats, St. Louis could turn to the bullpen before McGreevy gets a sixth-inning opportunity. That reduced workload creates an additional path for the under, independent of whether he pitches effectively.

Navigating a potent Dodgers lineup will only complicate matters. McGreevy can record several outs through balls in play, but that approach offers less protection when facing hitters who can punish mistakes and keep pressure on the pitcher.

The under is not dependent on McGreevy imploding; it can win if he allows contact, limits walks, and exits after roughly five innings with four or fewer strikeouts. His underlying metrics confirm that the statistical edge supports the under tonight, making this the most structurally sound play of the three recommendations.

Enjoying our betting coverage? Want more picks, predictions, and analysis from our proven experts? Make SBD a preferred source in your Google searches!

Michael Schwartz
Horse Racing

Recommended Reading