Love Island 2025: Winner Odds After Casa Amor Drama

• Love Island USA Season 7’s post-Casa Amor drama has shifted the odds, with Cierra and Nic emerging as favorites
• The failed Nicolandria experiment and Taylor’s surprising recoupling have oddsmakers scrambling
• Read below for the latest 2025 Love Island odds and expert predictions for the $100K prize

Casa Amor has done what it does best: create chaos. And the betting markets have responded accordingly.

Following forced couplings, shattered friendships, and the season’s most brutal game yet, BET99’s latest odds show clear favorites emerging from the villa’s wreckage. 

Let’s break down the latest 2025 Love Island odds and provide predictions as we approach the finale.

Love Island USA 2025 – Female Winner Odds

In the female odds to win Love Island, Cierra Ortega is the +165 favorite, giving her 37.7% implied win probability.

Love Island USA 2025 – Male Winner Odds

The Male Love Island winner odds price Nicolas Vansteenberghe as an equal +165 favorite as his partner Cierra, giving him a 37.6% implied chance to snag the grand prize.

BET365
SPORTSBOOK

Offer

T&Cs

Bet $5 & Get $150 in Bonus Bets Win or Lose or a First Bet Safety Net up to $1,000!

Deposit required. Paid in Bonus Bets. Bonus Bets wager excluded from returns. New Customers only. T&Cs, time limits and exclusions apply

LOCK IN PROMO

CODE: DIME365

CODE: DIME365

SIGNUP PROMO

BET $5
GET $150

OR GET UP TO $1,000 BACK

CLAIM OFFER

Odds as of July 2nd, at Bet99 Sportsbook. Canadian bettors can bet on Love Island odds with the Bet99 promo code. US residents should check out US betting sites.

Cierra & Nic Take the Lead

It was the moment every Love Island fan lives for. When Nic walked back into the villa alone, Cierra’s reaction was pure, unfiltered emotion. She flew into his arms, tears streaming down her face, in a scene that felt straight out of a romance movie.

That single, tear-filled embrace was reality TV gold, catapulting Cierra from a strong contender (+280) to the clear favorite at +165.

But it wasn’t just the reunion. Viewers are rewarding Cierra for her loyalty during Casa Amor. While others played the game, she couldn’t fake a connection with Elan to save her life. She gave him next to nothing, spending more time crying in the makeup room over Nic than trying to force a spark. Her authenticity is resonating, and it’s paying off big time.

Even a producer-forced “experiment” with Olandria couldn’t shake Nic. Tasked with coupling up to re-enter the villa, Nic gave it an honest shot, but his heart wasn’t in it.

By morning, Nick gracefully bowed out, admitting he was “too distracted thinking about Cierra anyway.” His unwavering focus has locked him in as the matching +165 favorite, making them the villa’s undeniable power couple.

Finding Value in the Love Island Odds

Amaya Espinal (+255)

Don’t sleep on Amaya “Papaya” Espinal. Her magnetic personality and infectious energy have built her a massive fanbase that could easily carry her to the finish line.

The latest challenge saw Zak criticize her for being “too emotional,” which fractured their connection and likely sent Amaya looking for a new partner.

At +255, she offers solid value because her popularity is independent of her coupling. A bet on Amaya is a bet on the villa’s top personality finding the right partner to win.

Ace Greene (+425)

Ace saw his chances take a hit after that controversial heart-rate challenge with Huda. But this is Love Island, and redemption arcs are everything.

If he and Chelley can navigate the drama, truly forgive each other, and get back on the same page, those +425 odds will look like an absolute steal in hindsight.

The Taylor-Olandria Fallout

In the season’s most shocking recoupling, Taylor chose Clarke, devastating Olandria and ending a three-week journey that viewers were deeply invested in.

The denial was painful to watch, especially when Olandria told Clarke that Taylor was just “using her to test their connection.”

Viewers were stunned, and the odds reflect the fallout. Taylor’s chances have slipped to +525, while a heartbroken Olandria has tumbled to +750. Clarke, the new variable in this equation, enters as a +1900 longshot, implying this new pairing is built on shaky ground.

Love Island 2025 Winner Predictions

Right now, Cierra and Nic (+165 each) are the smart and safe bet. Their separation-and-reunion arc is classic Love Island winner material.

But if you’re looking for the best value, it belongs to Amaya Espinal (+255). If a personality could win the show on its own, she’d be running away with it. With the potential of a new, more compatible partner after Zak, she’s a genuine threat to upset the favorites.

Best Bets:

• Male Winner: Nicolas Vansteenberghe (+165)
• Female Winner: Cierra Ortega (+165)
• Value: Amaya Espinal (+255)

The finale is just around the corner, but for now, the couple that proved they couldn’t fake it looks poised to take home the $100,000.