Cardinals vs Blue Jays Predictions, Props & Splits on Sunday

• The Toronto Blue Jays look for a sereis sweep as -120 favorites vs the St Louis Cardinals
• St Louis has been held to a single run in back-to-back games
• Read below for the my Cardinals vs Blue Jays predictions, props updated odds and betting splits

---

The Toronto Blue Jays will look for their first series sweep since taking three in Boston in mid-June, as they wrap up their 3-game set against the Cardinals on Sunday.

After opening with a 3-1 win Friday, Toronto maximized opportunities behind stars like Vladimir Guerrero Jr, scoring five runs on nine hits in a 5-1 triumph.

The books like them for their fourth win in a row overall, setting Toronto as home favorites in the MLB odds.

First pitch goes at 1:37pm ET today from Rogers Centre in Toronto, with MLB TV providing the broadcast coverage.

Cardinals vs Blue Jays Prediction

• Over 9 runs (-110 at Caesars)

The MLB probable pitchers mmediately points toward a high-scoring affair. Both starters have struggled immensely to limit damage this season.

Max Scherzer searches for answers after a brutal start to his 2026 campaign. Holding a 1-4 record alongside a towering 9.49 ERA and an 8.21 FIP, Scherzer is consistently getting punished.

Over his last 10 appearances, the veteran right-hander has surrendered an alarming 3.28 home runs per nine innings. He is also walking 5.11 batters per nine over that span. Compounding his issues is a lack of longevity, as he averages just 3.52 innings per start.

On the visitors’ side, Matthew Liberatore enters with better underlying metrics but still leaves much to be desired. Sporting a 5.26 overall ERA and a bloated 1.56 WHIP, the left-hander has a tough time stranding runners. Opponents hold a .296 batting average against him.

While Liberatore generates more swings and misses—boasting an 8.77 K/9 rate overall—he similarly struggles to pitch deep into games. He averages just 4.60 innings per start recently.

Given their mutual propensity for allowing traffic on the basepaths, betting the Over 9 (-110) is my top angle for the game total.

STL Cardinals vs TOR Blue Jays Props

Pick: Matthew Liberatore Under 3.5 Strikeouts (+128 at Caesars): Liberatore routinely struggles to miss bats away from Busch Stadium. He has failed to exceed 3.5 strikeouts in 12 of his last 15 road outings—an 80% success rate for the under.

Pick: Masyn Winn Over 0.5 Hits (-193 at DraftKings): Winn has recorded at least one base hit in six of his last seven regular-season games, an 86% cover rate.

Pick: Lars Nootbaar Under 0.5 Hits (+142 at DraftKings): Nootbaar has failed to record a hit in 75% of his last four road games.

Cardinals vs Blue Jays Odds & Betting Splits

The graphic above shows the best available odds, which are subject to change. Be sure to use the BetMGM promo code to bet on Cardinals vs Blue Jays or any other MLB game. And don’t forget to check out the MLB batter vs pitcher stats before making your prop bets.

The current MLB odds slot the hometown Blue Jays as slight moneyline favorites at -112, with St. Louis is positioned as an even-money underdog at +102 (both odds from FanDuel).

Toronto is getting 1.5 runs on the spread, but the tax comes with heavy -190 odds from bet365. The Cardinals are also catching 1.5 runs on the spread, and that pays out at -184 at FD.

The game total is set at 9.0 runs, with the Over paying out at -109 odds at DraftKings, and -106 odds for the Under.

Looking at MLB public betting splits, the betting public heavily backs Toronto, with 77% of moneyline tickets favoring the home team with 64% of the handle on the Jays.

It’s even more Toronto-heavy on the spread, with 82% of the tickets and 74% of the money on the home team.

In the total market, splits are much more unified. Bettors heavily anticipate a lower-scoring affair, with 64% of tickets backing the Under. The money percentage tells an identical story, as 53% of the handle supports the Under.