Upcoming Match-ups

Printable Super Bowl 58 Props Sheet – Download the 2024 PDF & Play at Your Party

Matt McEwan

by Matt McEwan in NFL Football

Updated Feb 11, 2024 · 8:19 PM PST

SBD's printable Super Bowl props sheet
  • Every good Super Bowl party needs a props sheet for all guests to fill out
  • I appreciate not all Super Bowl party guests are avid football fans, so I offer two different props sheets for your party to choose from – or use both!
  • Download the PDF below and print off your 2024 Super Bowl props sheets

Preparing for a Super Bowl party can be a lot of work. You have to clean the house, pick up some beverages (to be consumed responsibly, of course), ensure there is proper seating for everyone, cook the food, and more. So, you worry about the food, drinks, seating, and cleanliness of your house, and allow me to handle your Super Bowl props sheets to ensure maximum entertainment at your party. (If you’re not hosting, I’m happy to help you be the hero that handles the props sheets.)

I’m also very aware that it’s possible not everyone at your party will know who Brandon Aiyuk is. Other guests might not know Usher’s biggest tracks. And, of course, some might just be there for Taylor Swift. I don’t want any of these people feeling left out, and so I have created two different Super Bowl props sheets:  one for the hardcore football fan and one for the more casual fan. Personally, I like to fill out both.

The PDFs for both printable 2024 Super Bowl props sheets can be found below. You will want to follow @SBD on Twitter/X, where we will be tweeting the answers live, or bookmark this page to come back and check in on the live answers in the table below. (If you’re looking for more action on the big game, check out the best Super Bowl betting promos.)

2024 Super Bowl Props Sheet for Hardcore NFL Fans

Super Bowl props sheet for hardcore fans

>> Download Printable Super Bowl 58  Props Sheet for Hardcore Fans <<

Though it may be obvious to some, I want to ensure it is obvious to all: anytime you see a “___” in the props sheet above, it means you fill in your own answer.

When it comes to Question #3, it’s important to know the opening kickoff does not count as a play. The correct answer will be the first offensive play run after the kickoff. In Question #14, the “4th Quarter” answer would include overtime, should the game be tied at the end of the fourth quarter.

In Questions #15 & #16, you will notice there is a handicap being applied. At the end of the game, we will add 15.5 passing yards to Brock Purdy’s passing yards before comparing against Patrick Mahomes’. The same goes for Isiah Pacheco in Question #16, who will have 40.5 yards from scrimmage added to his total before being graded against Christian McCaffrey. In Question #20, if neither player gets a sack, you will just mark all answers right/wrong – you choose what you want to do. (I mark all wrong.) In Question #22 on who will cover the spread, if the 49ers end up winning by exactly two points, it will be a push. So, once again, you can either mark all answers right or wrong.

Also, be sure everyone fills out a tiebreaking question. I always go with total number of points scored in the game.

2024 Super Bowl Props Sheet for the Casual Fan

Super Bowl props sheet for casual fans

>> Download Printable Super Bowl 58 Props Sheet for Casual Fans <<

There are a few things to clarify in this sheet as well. In Question #5 on who will Taylor Swift be shown with first, commercials do not count and we will not start counting until the Super Bowl broadcast begins. In Question #7 on how quickly Swift will be shown, commercials do not count again and we are using the time on the game clock. So, if she is shown for the first time with 12:31 left on the clock in the first quarter, then “YES” would be correct. If there is any less than 10:00 on the clock when she is shown for the first time, then “NO” will be correct.

In Question #12, it does not matter if the penalty is accepted or not. As long as the referees throw a flag and announce a penalty, then that is enough for “YES” to be correct. In Question #15, the fourth quarter will also include overtime if necessary.

FANDUEL SPORTSBOOK
Bet $5 & Get $150 If Your Bet Wins!

Must be 21+. T&C Apply. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

LOCK IN PROMO
SIGNUP PROMO
BET $5
GET $150

BET NOW

In Questions #18 and #19, Ludacris / Lil Jon would actually have to perform with Usher on stage. It is not enough for a picture/hologram to be shown. In Question #25, the Super Bowl MVP does not have to explicitly say “thank you.” The correct answer will just be who they mention/reference first in their speech.

Be sure everyone fills out some tiebreaking question as well. As mentioned above, I always go with total number of points scored, but feel free to do whatever you like. (Just be sure you pick a question that people are unlikely to give the same answer to.)

2024 Super Bowl Props Sheet Answers

Question Hardcore Props Sheet Answer Casual Props Sheet Answer
1 OVER OVER
2 HEADS BLACK
3 RUN YES
4 NO MAHOMES
5 SAN FRANCISCO OTHER (BLAKE LIVELY)
6 FIELD GOAL HEADS
7 CHRISTIAN MCCAFFREY NO
8 YES OTHER
9 FUMBLE SAN FRANCISCO
10 YES FIELD GOAL
11 OVER YES
12 NO YES
13 YES OVER
14 4TH SAN FRANCISCO
15 MAHOMES 4TH
16 MCCAFFREY WHITE
17 KELCE NO
18 RICE YES
19 VALDES-SCANTLING YES
20 OTHER (CAUGHT UP)
21 KANSAS CITY YEAH!
22 KANSAS CITY KANSAS CITY
23 UNDER (PURPLE) OTHER (PURPLE)
24 OTHER MAHOMES
25 MAHOMES TEAMMATES

I’ll be updating the table above with the answers live during Super Bowl 58. If you do not see any answers filled in, just refresh the page.

Need Some Help Filling Out Your Super Bowl Props Sheet?

Whether you’re unsure about which player will win Super Bowl MVP or have no clue what song Usher might open the halftime show with, I have you covered. Below you’ll find a bunch of resources that will help answer most questions in each sheet. Please do keep in mind, the most probable answer is not always the correct one. So, don’t blame me if you lose!

Author Image